Updated They're Real dupe?

I've searched previous posts and found they're mostly a few years old.

The brown shade of this mascara seriously lives up to its name, I'm a natural redhead and never buy black or black/brown mascara. I've even tried other Benefit mascaras and they're not the same. A combination of the formula, colour, and spoolie is something I haven't been able to recreate. Price isn't always an issue for a dependable product, it was usually around $30 at Shoppers, but I haven't been able to find the brown shade anywhere and think it might be discontinued?

Currently using a dark brown Dior mascara after asking someone at Sephora for a similar product, but it still comes across as black, is flaky/clumpy, and costs more. My go-to drugstore brand is NYX but I've been dipping into the e.l.f. world with some success. I've heard they have a brown mascara but a)it was out of stock at my last store and b)I don't know if it's anything like the colour/formula/spoolie of They're Real.

If you couldn't tell by the "u" in colour or Shoppers Drug Mart reference I'm in Canada lol and western to be specific so if I'm not buying it with PC points I'm getting it from London Drugs. Don't know if that makes a difference ¯⁠\⁠_⁠(⁠ツ⁠)⁠_⁠/⁠¯

Thanks!