6x15 White as the Driven Snow [Spoilers!]
Watching the show for the first time, just now finished this episode. For a quick refresher, Richard Haibach has kidnapped Van Pelt (with the help of his sister), and Jane and Rigsby kidnap him and trick him into taking them to where he has Van Pelt hidden.
Now, I have a lot of issues with this episode. It hits on my biggest pet peeve of cop dramas, which is a show being completely uncritical towards cops breaking the law, mistreating suspects, or generally abusing the system and their power. In this episode, Jane and Rigsby kidnap a lawyer and her client (who has just been released from custody since there is zero evidence linking him to any crime), and then strand the lawyer in the middle of nowhere after stealing her phone, and proceed to kidnap and then begin to torture Richard. And at this point, for all they know, Richard is entirely innocent. Not that I think that matters.
At this point of the show, I began rooting for the horrible pedophile kidnapper. Because this guy has been abused by these cops nonstop (literally tortured almost to death because Jane decided he probably deserved it, and as we see in the episode is now permanently scarred), and now police are beating him, kidnapping him, literally dousing him in gasoline and threatening to burn him alive. Not to mention everyone at the FBI acting like the lawyer is evil for not... rolling over on her client? I get that there's a bad guy and he did a bad thing and needs to get caught, but the justice system exists for a reason.
Now, I get that this is different than a normal episode. This isn't just some guy kidnapping some woman, he kidnapped Van Pelt. And I would be totally fine if the episode had Rigsby crossing the line multiple times and then acknowledged that he did. Even if it's still overall framed as a "good" thing, since he saves Grace (which is a moral debate I won't get into). But the episode literally ends with a big FBI director coming in and telling him how much of a good job he did, and that he should come work at the FBI. Rigsby should be in jail at the end of the episode.
The show normally toes the line on following the letter of the law and getting your own justice. I mean hell, they had the guts to just let Jane murder Red John in cold blood (twice). And I think it's totally fine in those cases, because he's not an officer of the law, and he faces consequences for those actions. And everyone else (of note, the law enforcement officers) condemn these actions, and do their best to do their duty to prevent them. I'm okay with Jane going outside the lines, and being reprimanded and told he needs to follow the system, even though his breaking the rules gets results. But I hate it when a show takes the position that rules and laws are just there to get in the way of cops "getting the bad guys".
It's extra baffling that this starts to become more prevalent at the same time as a big plot about a cabal of corrupt cops covering for eachother became a major plot point
Posted Oct 14, 2023, 3:56 AM UTC