Domain-Local vs Universal, help me

I am studying for my AZ-800 exam, and I cannot for the life of my get this distinction through my head. Whenever I encounter a question that involves Group Scope, I almost ALWAYS confuse these 2 scopes.

Is there an acid test I can do on a question that will help me determine whether Domain-Local or Universal scope is needed? I am losing my mind here

Posted Nov 4, 2023, 1:53 PM UTC

313
jamesaepp•

I believe the wikipedia page on AGDLP is one of the best explanations on ADDS group scopes.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AGDLP

14
A-Bearded-IdiotSysadmin•

Have a look at the AGDLP nesting strategy as a practical approach to choosing proper group scope. The scopes are easy to confuse in a single domain environment because they mostly behave the same until you start managing multiple domain forests or require a domain trust scenario, such as your company acquiring another company and you need to onboard and migrate their existing AD structure and permissions into your managed environment.

Here is a video I found useful when learning this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zHHzjjqVhTc

FeatureDomain LocalGlobalUniversal
ScopeSingle DomainSingle DomainEntire AD Forest
Can contain members fromAny domainOwn domain onlyAny domain in the forest
Can be granted permissions onResources in any domainResources in any domainResources in any domain
Can be a member ofOther domain local groups, Universal groupsDomain local and Universal groupsUniversal groups only
ReplicationWithin the domainWithin the domainAcross the entire forest
Use CaseAssigning permissions to resources that are domain-specificGrouping users in a specific domain that share similar access requirementsGrouping users from multiple domains that need similar access across the forest
7
sambodia85Windows Admin•

Yep, that’s the video I use for every new starter in my team. There’s a follow up with AGUDLP which also good, but the first one nails the concept.

2
IPFR33LY•

Domain local groups Domain local security groups are most often used to assign permissions for access to resources. You can assign these permissions only in the same domain where you create the domain local group. Members from any domain may be added to a domain local group.

The domain local scope can contain user accounts, universal groups, and global groups from any domain. In addition, the scope can both contain and be a member of domain local groups from the same domain.

Global groups Global security groups are most often used to organize users who share similar network access requirements. Members can be added only from the domain in which the global group was created. A global group can be used to assign permissions for access to resources in any domain. The global scope can contain user accounts and global groups from the same domain, and can be a member of universal and domain local groups in any domain.

Universal groups Universal security groups are most often used to assign permissions to related resources in multiple domains. Members from any domain may be added. Also, you can use a universal group to assign permissions for access to resources in any domain. Universal security groups are not available in mixed mode. The full feature set of Windows 2000 and later Microsoft NT-based operating systems is available only in native mode. The universal scope can contain user accounts, universal groups, and global groups from any domain. The scope can be a member of domain local or universal groups in any domain.

6
martinfendertaylor•

This is as clear as mud. Thank you MS. I'll get my lawyers to interpret.

/S

3
IPFR33LY•

I think you need to learn Active Directory forests, this should be crystal clear if you have an understanding of how active directory domains and forests work.

6
OsmiumBalloon•

I think you need to learn Active Directory forests,

I do believe that is what OP is trying to do.

3
IPFR33LY•

He's trying to learn azure hybrid services. active is more basic. I'd suggest reading up on AD functionality before layering on Azure hybrid infrastructure.

5
martinfendertaylor•

Thanks for clarifying OPs question. I'm sure copy pasta helped a ton.

2
ANewLeeSinLifeSysadmin•

Did you even read what you copy and pasted? You start talking about mixed mode operation without even describing it. It also has absolutely nothing to do with AGDLP. That's incredibly poor from an educational perspective.

It fails to mention anything about the global catalog which is an actual reason to be careful about choosing group types.

It also fails to provide any form of guidance on why you should use any of them. Both DL and G types can hold domain users, but the AGDLP guidance is that DL groups should only contain Global groups while Global groups should only contain user and computer objects. It's the whole reason the acronym exists.

Account > Global > Domain Local > Permissions

2
martinfendertaylor•

Thanks. 20+ years bro. I think you need to learn what /s means it's crystal clear if you have an understanding of how reddit works.

1
OsmiumBalloon•
  • Universal groups
  • Effectively exist throughout the entire forest
  • Can contain
    • Anything in the forest, except a local group
    • Nothing from outside the forest (trusts)
  • Can be members of
    • Local and universal groups only
  • Global groups
  • Exist within a domain, but are known to the forest and trusts
  • Can contain anything from
    • Any domain (forest or trust)
    • Universals span domains, so none of them
  • Can be a member of
    • Any local or universal group (forest or trust)
    • Global groups in the same domain
  • Local groups
    • Exist within a domain, known to trusts only
    • Can contain
      • Local groups, if from the same domain
      • Anything else, from any domain (forest or trust)
    • Can be members of
      • Local groups in the same domain only

The "Exists" parts are my terminology and my concept, but I find it helpful to my understanding, and I suspect reflect the original design intent. Something can only be a member of something else if the something else is within the same scope of existence.

3
TaiGlobal•
  1. There's an azure sub that might be better suited for this question: https://www.reddit.com/r/AZURE/

  2. I don't blame you. I'm studying for AZ-900 and I still barely understand what Microsoft considers SAAS, PAAS, IAAS. It's to the point I'm just going to memorize all their core services and what they consider what and if I see any of those core services mentioned I'll just know what it is (e.g. Intune is Saas).

For example look at an answer below regarding if Azure Storage services are Iaas or Paas

That completely depends on the definition and services and do not forget most of the cloud services have evolved to a model that blurs the line between IaaS and PaaS

Azure Storage Services can be categorized under both IaaS and PaaS, depending on the use case.

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/answers/questions/1341827/are-azure-storage-services-characterized-as-iaas-o

2