Government’s proposed new laws to target homeless people could be used to prosecute wildcampers?

Misc

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-67321319.amp

It’s isn’t mentioned in the text of the story but it was the first thing that came to my mind.

The proposal is to make a criminal offence of tents causing a nuisance. Police and private land owners could definitely use this to prosecute wild campers.

What do we think?

Posted Nov 4, 2023, 8:37 PM UTC

5745
IAmBigDumbIdiot•

Good spot but I highly doubt it will be used to prosecute wildcampers much tbh. It is concerning for sure, but I think the more people that respectively leave no trace, interact well with the public, and promote responsible outdoor adventurous pursuits, then the lower chance of prosecution. From my experience, genuinely talking to the landowner with genuine respect and willingness to see their side, you’ll rarely find yourself in an altercation.

Doesn’t change the fact that it’s so fucking depressing to see the homeless once again being attacked for issues that are not initially caused by them. The Tory government are the scum of the UK. Self serving pricks.

60
wgilpin•

Just like the anti-terror legislation wouldn't be used to stop hecklers at conference, eh Mr Blair?

11
robmorpethOP•

I didn’t really want to get political but I agree with you on the Tories. This is a cheap attempt at winning votes in certain boroughs of London.

Apart from that, I’m sure most wildcampers will be unaffected and many landowners will continue as is. However I can see situations where overzealous landowners or police officers may try to use such a law to prosecute us unfortunately.

10
Aysandra•

I agree that unfortunately there is potential in this awful legislation to cause trouble for us as well.

Technically even in Scotland you can be moved from a camp of you're 'causing nuisance'. This will just add weight in disputes and may need to play out in courts before we see the full impact - if it goes through, of course.

1
redevilgak•

I was going to post, but you've pretty much summed up what I think, and most people do about the tories.

7
worldsinho•

That’s angry comment but don’t most people dislike tents and homeless people kicking around?

There’s other help and solutions to move them away.

2
clodiusmetellus•

I personally think this is quite a self-centred read on this legislation. It's an attempt to criminalise homelessness, they're not going to go after middle class hikers in their £500 ultralight tents.

21
robmorpethOP•

Definitely a self centred take on it, I don’t dispute that. The issue I foresee is that certain landowners or authorities who are against wild camping will see this legislation and try to utilise it for their own purpose.

For what it’s worth so believe that prosecuting homeless people in this way is a disgrace and instead of looking to change legislation the government should be trying to solve the causes of the homelessness (instead of being the root cause themselves). But this isn’t a place to discuss politics, just wild camping.

13
S3THI3•

True, landowners especially commercial have lawyers on retainer who know the owners concerns and keep an eye out for exactly this kind of thing and could be contributing to the lobby.

Some people think of it (I think naively) as an unforeseen circumstance of legislation, others think it's purposely baked in.

3

£550 I'll have you know.

8
VARIAN-SCOTT•

£1100 terra nova expidition quasar.. “insert dicaprio” meme here

3
00DEADBEEF•

What about plebs like me in our Lanshans?

3
00DEADBEEF•

The police aren't going to bother going up the hills to chase off wild campers. Easier pickings in the cities where they can bully the homeless.

19

Remember, it's a lifestyle choice.

16
blindfoldedbadgers•

It’s a failure of the government (the home office, specifically - the exact people pushing this law).

13
Manofyear21•

Like they wouldn't use drones in lockdown to follow walkers around the Derbyshire countryside to prosecute them.

4
00DEADBEEF•

That was landowners, not police. I also haven't heard of any prosecutions. Do you have a source?

0
Manofyear21•

No it was Police, and yes I have a source.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-derbyshire-52055201

3
00DEADBEEF•

That's not a source for prosecutions

0
GodAtum•

Unfortunately you’re wrong. Geo wizard was caught by police in the middle of nowhere in one of his videos.

1
00DEADBEEF•

You mean the British Transport Police?

1
GodAtum•

No the police

2
robmorpethOP•

BTP are the police. It’s right there in the name. Same powers, sworn in police officers.

1
Manofyear21•

Dude give it up!

1
00DEADBEEF•
1
Max_Abbott_1979•

I think you’re absolutely right on this. After the ongoing problems with wealthy landowners such as Alexander Darwall, the hedge fund manager, trying to end wild camping in places like Dartmoor, this is exactly the type of back door they want. He is a Tory party donor just to be absolutely clear.

15
StillJustJones•

I reckon you’re right. They WILL use this legislation to clamp down on wild campers.

Posters who think that the middle classes are safe are out of touch.

The beardy Peter Storm wearing ramblers sipping from their thermos flasks are about as middle class as you can get and yet the agg they get from toffee nosed landowners is famously awful.

9
Norfolk_an_Chance•

This is just dog whistle politics, they are probably trying to divert our attention from other things, note that she said that some of them are foreign nationals.

I doubt this move will impact Wild Camping or indeed the homelessness problem,

Meanwhile, Finland have nearly irradiated homelessness, why aren't we copying their methodology?

“The nation of Finland positioned itself as a global leader in combating homelessness. Through an innovative public policy strategy that has virtually eliminated homelessness within its borders, Finland has redefined how nations can address homelessness. By focusing on prevention, early intervention, and a comprehensive support system through wraparound services, Finland has shown the world that homelessness is a solvable problem”.

Eradicating Homelessness in Finland

3
robmorpethOP•

Well the government could do a lot of things to make motive the social issues in this country but they choose not to. Because they’re capitalists and globalists and don’t want to spend our tax money to help us, just to give tax breaks to those who need them least.

1
pigscantdrivecars•

Imagine a first world country where we're persecute and attack the homeless, people that have nothing at all, so let's punish them Welcome to tory Britain

3
Max_Abbott_1979•

Hopefully the BMC / ramblers and others are aware of this.

2
whoops53•

I think there is a difference between pitching a tent in a carpark, and having one in Finsbury Park. But yeah, overall I think its a loophole which will be exploited and its disgusting. Especially with the blatant offerings of homes to incoming non tax payers.

2
Best-Baseball-2462•

Oh who gives. Sod the police and the bloody law makers. Keep wild camping and keep enjoying it. Don’t give anyone a reason to complain. We’re entitled to the outdoors. The world belongs to us 🙌

2
Nerevear248•

This was on my explore page, but I’m currently doing an assignment on this subject in my law degree. The coincidence that the question we are doing was advertised as fictitious, and then this actually happening is very strange lol

2
chrisjwoodall•

Yes it isn’t aimed at us but in a world where the Darwalls went to court to argue about what constitutes recreation, your point is valid - although I doubt the police will actively pursue it, it’s one test case away from it.

In practice though will this not hinge on the definition of ‘nuisance’? To us and those sleeping rough? And if so could it inform a debate that helps separate what we do from the ‘fly camping’ and its attendant nuisance that’s used a brush to tar us with?

2
Invisible_blood•

I’m going to sound mental here but can’t we sort out the homeless people with houses and stuff, like if we can give military aid and money to this country because people are struggling with the basic human needs then why don’t the government make it a priority to get these people sorted out and stop it from happening. I’ve saw the ban on smoking, what about alcohol or the use of opioids on prescription? You can’t just clean one room in the house and hope it stops stinking! Mr. Speaker here here here clowns 🤡

2
robmorpethOP•

Sounds mental

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
aspghost•

I imagine more than that it'll be used against activist camps.

1
One-Aspect-4123•

Sleep in a grave? Or the glorious uk gov urban spike beds

1
Permaculture_hings•

I feel sorry for English people. Not even allowed to walk about their own country or go camping , shite floating in the rivers etc.

1
papertiger61•

So Americans want the homeless to lie in the gutter. Well, it is the greatest country in the world and has universal health care. So they must care for their citizens.

-8
apintofbestplease•

What’s this got to do with Americans?

5