Job wants overpayment back.

So a job I quit 4 months ago just contacted me saying they did their financial audit and found out they double paid me for a check they messed up on. Thing is, I notified them twice. I talked directly to the president and told him directly that they paid me in a check then direct deposited the $1400 2 weeks later. He talked to me like I was an idiot both times and said it was them making things right. Second time I asked if I'm good to keep the money and he said yes. My dumbass didn't get it in writing. Just got the text today that they want it back.

I know I'm supposed to pay them back, but I went 2 months without work and am flat broke since starting my new job. Anyone know if I could find a way to avoid paying them since I was directly told by the president I can keep the money? Figured I'd ask before I responded to him with rage calling him an idiot like he did to me. I'll add that place had the most mismanaged office. Never got a single correct check from that place. If you called them at any point guarantee no one would get back to you for days. Even as a customer.

Posted Nov 7, 2023, 12:30 AM UTC

15092
Budd0413•

Can’t get blood from a stone, and tbh the litigation would cost them more than it’s worth, been there done that. ….. fuck em

158
Teauxny•

This is the correct reply. I say this having had the same experience. Ghost 'em.

64
junglegroove•

My x had thar happened and they tried to do a reverse auto draft it declined and nothing happened. He worked for a bank.

10

"ya boss have your lawyer call deez nuuuutz"

gif

1
Parking_Type•

Small claims is relatively inexpensive and they could have the court costs included in their judgement (in California) and considering OP has an indefensible position I would not recommend just blowing them off. You owe them the money and the responsible adult thing thing to do is pay them back and I am sure that payment over time could be arranged.

1
Budd0413•

Just being curious but how old are you? Roughly if you’re not comfortable saying

1
Signal_Ad2099•

If it were me tell them if they want it get it run through official channels i.e. have them produce a copy of the check you deposited and the record of thier bank depositing into your bank to ensure that you are not going to over pay them. NAL but someone might have some legal advice on making them submit something to a court to ensure proper payment is made not some dude who sent a text/email with unverified demands. In any case do it all with paper trail so they don't come after you twice.

107

After doing the verification, offer, via a certified mail letter, return receipt requested, to pay them back $20 biweekly (assuming that's how your paid) and include the first check along with the payment schedule. Make them send the check back to you as it's my understanding (not a lawyer) that if they cash even 1 check, that's acceptance of the payback schedule. Even if they do send back your check, keep doing it until they tell you to stop, Always check with a lawyer.

30
Harrigan_Raen•

Also, if this over paymnet was done last year. You need an amended W2 and they need to pay to have your taxes re-done and filed.

30
j_the_a•

You will almost certainly have to pay it back.

There are a few exceptions. It's worth a call to a reputable employment attorney in your location for a free consultation to make sure.

51
HellagingeOP•

Thanks for letting me know. Not what I want to see, but figured I'd throw a hail Mary.

20
Oldpuzzlehead•

A few states have laws that say if the overpayment is without fault on the individual's part, the individual is not liable to repay the amount.

23
BastienbardSocDem :dems:•

One of the few exceptions would be the president of the company telling you to keep it...

15
ButCanYouCodeIt•

...if you have hard proof of that..which, being a verbal conversation, I'm guessing OP doesn't have a recording of that.

-1
CrimsonWolfSage•

And some states say it's illegal to record. However, for record keeping... an email summary of events to confirm with that group/person can be useful!

4
ButCanYouCodeIt•

At an old job, I had a boss asking me to do some sketchy things. So, maintaining s professional demeanor and tone, I explained that I "had a lot on my plate, and didn't want to forget what he wanted me to do, so if he could email that to me I would appreciate it. So I don't forget." Lol. Months later, there was a larger internal investigation, and sure enough what he asked me to do turned out to be a small portion of that. That email saved my ass. I don't think you can realistically pull that truck off everywhere though.

4

I'm probably wrong but ... ignore them. What are they going to do? Sue you for $1.4k? Nothing bad will happen, I guess your credit score might take a hit at some point. Stop answering their calls, texts, emails, etc.

35

They/this will NOT affect OP's credit score. Credit scores only apply to bills that go to collection or credit card payments. Their only means of recovery are through the court.

5
NCC1701-Enterprise•

And once they have a judgement from the court it can go into collections and end up on the credit report.

3

That would be true if there's a judgment that OP did not pay. They won't be able to get a judgment unless they get a hearing for which defendant would be notified.

1
Vapordude420:420:•

The CEO told you that you don't have to pay it back. Don't pay it back. It doesn't matter that it isn't in writing.

29
TapirWarrior•

Most states do allow for handshake agreements, unfortunately it would come down to your word vs their word. And personal experience shows most people will lie in court to save themselves a dime unless there is a paper trail.

23
Vapordude420:420:•

Yes. But who has the money now? OP Who needs something? It isn't OP

7
jerquee•

yes they can lie, and it's the job of the judge (or jury) to figure out who's lying. Not that this would ever get to that point.

3
TapirWarrior•

You're not wrong, and in a perfect world they would dig for the truth. However, in the event of a he said she said argument the court would side with where there is paperwork. Or on the side of the business.

2†
jerquee•

Why do you say that? Do you have a lot of experience in court cases?

2
protomatterman•

Change your phone number. Your 1st mistake was letting them know. My previous company paid me my bonus after I had already quit. It was in March for the previous year so technically I did deserve this. But in practice I know they don’t do that. There were so many changes I’m sure it slipped through the cracks. I just kept my mouth shut and have heard nothing about it.

17
TravelingGonad•

4 months fuck em make them work for it if they want it so bad. Ignore them.

15

I would completely ignore them and move on with my life. There’s no world where they’re going to sue you for $1400. Fighting it would cost them more than that. I bet you they’ll just write it off.

14
NCC1701-Enterprise•

There’s no world where they’re going to sue you for $1400.

Really? you think they wouldn't spend $100 on a filing fee to go to small claims? I have seen companies go legal of less than a $1.

The company is going to sue, they are going to hope he ignores the summons and they get a summary judgement then they sell the debt to a collection agency for $600.

2
INotcryingyouare•

Nope, you have to pay back an overpayment. It will seriously bite you if you don't.

10
HellagingeOP•

Guess they'll be getting it in either pennies or in a payment plan of $5 checks every single day with "for the idiot who can't do their job" in the memo. Unless someone else has an idea. I could have sworn I got him to text me that I could keep the money, but I can't find the text. No proof he verbally told me. Gah! I'm just pissed and stressed.

13
NonsenseScenario•

Call him

-3
Boobsiclese•

Absolutely NOT.

🤦‍♀️

OP do everything, if anything, in writing.

1
NonsenseScenario•

Lol "hey remember that money you said I could keep? There must've been a miscommunication with accounting because they're trying to take it back" "OH shoot, let me take care of that for you"

Would be a lot easier and quicker. Yall watch too much tv

-2
BastienbardSocDem :dems:•

Not when the president of the company makes a statement that you rely on that ends up being detrimental to yourself if needed to be paid back.

-1
Mortimer452•

I agree with others, probably obligated to pay them back. If it were me in the same situation, I'd probably ghost them for a few days first and see if they continue hounding you, they might give up easily.

7
FluffyDoodle•

Go silent and ignore them.

6
grumpycat1968•

don't pay them back

5
HellagingeOP•

In MN I'm pretty sure they can sue and garnish my wages at my new job. I would need legal recourse in that case, which IDK if I even have it.

7

It will cost them more to sue and garnish than they'll recover ($1400).

15
ccx941•

Some people are petty enough to do that.

4
akaenragedgoddess•

Sure, but even if OP gets sued and loses, it buys him time. On the other hand, they may not bother suing or they may sue and lose. His best option is to tell them to pound sand.

3
akaenragedgoddess•

Make them spend the effort and time getting it back. You have a legitimate dispute in that the CEO told you it's yours to keep, twice. Worst case scenario, they sue, you lose the case and have to pay them back. Best case, they don't even bother suing. Second best, they sue and lose. Chances are decent for either the first best or second best case.

You don't work for them anymore, which is usually how companies leverage people into paying back overpayment, they can just do deductions from following paychecks. They don't have that option now, so if you disagree that you owe them, the only thing they can do is sue. They're hoping you just give in easily.

6
MrBadBadly•

Play coy with them. Tell them to submit proof of their over payment and that you can't repay them simply based on their word. If they mention you bringing up the over payment in the past, again, play coy and go "Huh, I did? What was the result of the conversation at that time?"

If they provide proof/evidence, you can try to work up a repayment plan with them. If they refuse, I would refuse to repay them until evidence is provided. And if they admit to the prior conversation, I would follow up with why didn't pursue repayment then when it would have been less of a burden for all involved.

3
btm4you3•

I would say I want CERTIFIED copies of everything from the bank. How do you know they aren't making fake checks to show you.

1
PMProfessor•

Not a lawyer.

If they sue, it'll be in small claims court. Show up, and tell the judge what happened. They'll need to prove there was an overpayment and the president of the company would have to state under oath that he didn't forgive the overpayment. Meaning he'd need to take the day off, show up in court and lie under oath.

Likely they won't even show up in court. If you do and they don't, it's a default judgement.

1
SuckerForNoirRobots:420: Stoned Freelancer :420:•

You could try responding with, "I squared this away with [President] on [Date(s)]." And see what happens. Worst outcome is that nothing changes.

5
Oldpuzzlehead•

Depends on where you live. Some states in the US block employers from collecting overpayments. If in another country look up yours laws before just giving them the money back.

4
skyy1999•

At my company, we had a salary employee whose termination was not processed upon him leaving and he was over paid $3,500 and we did not get him to sign the overpayment letter, I work in HR but I do not believe our payroll team sued him for it, but I am unsure. We require all employees to sign a letter before deducting the overpayment and recently we had 16+ people over paid by 3 hours who were already terminated and I brought this to our payrolls attention and they did nothing.

4
matty_nice•

Given what you said, I would respond that you consider the matter resolved. Respond the company that you spoke with the President who told you it was not an error. Give them approximate dates and whatever information you have. But ultimately, you dont own them anything. Put the burden on them.

2
Green_Mix_3412•

He said she said. Tell em no. Remind them you notified them of this and they told you to keep it 1400 isn’t worth getting a lawyer they would likely back down.

2
SoCalGuy11011•

You’re good. Worst case they can probably try and small claims it but it would hardly be worth the effort. Just ignore them

2
311196•

I wouldn't reply at all. Whose to say that's even your number anymore. It's been 4 months, and if they're as mismanaged as you say. Then they won't take you to court over $1,400.

2
Emalix•

I don’t think you recieved this message. Your changed your phone number a month ago.

2