Need a plot hook for a certain event

Hello, I am a new DM running my first campaign. Soon, my players will be entering a new section of the story which is largely sandbox. I wanted to do this because my campaign and story have been fairly linear so far and I wanted to open up the world and allow them to mingle with it as they please. One of the plot hooks for this open world segment is a battle arena with a competitive ladder of sorts that promises great prizes as a reward for beating the champion in ritual combat. The major twist is that the champion is one of the player character’s older siblings that they have not seen in a long time, and provided that the players choose to participate in this combat arena I want that particular character to be the guy who faces off against the champion so that he can have a cool character moment that will lead to some important backstory stuff. My only problem is that I am unsure of how I can encourage this one party member to fight while stopping anyone else from doing it for that particular fight without too much railroading. I’m not afraid of using a little bit of railroading for keeping the story and session on track but I don’t want to feel like I’m limiting the possibilities of other players during that time. What do I do? All advice is appreciated of course.

Posted Nov 13, 2023, 11:05 PM UTC

26
ButIfYouThink•

It's a tournament, all the PCs participate.

The older sibling uses a partial mask or has a face covering helmet, and goes by a fighting name, as do several fighting NPCs.

The PC wins their first round, goes up against the older sibling NPC. The rest of it, the exposure, fight, etc is up to you.

3
krichcomix•

Have it be one on one, the long lost sibling is the defending champion, and it's the champion's right to pick the opposing combatant.

1
AlexD2003OP•

Dang that’s pretty good. Thanks

1
aDMnamedDoug•

You could let the group enter into the tournament when offered rewards for winning. Maybe four rounds and they get a chance to face the champion. Each round increase the CR rating. Longer they go the higher the rewards. A single healing potion to each member between rounds. One short rest before the final. Now you lead to the crowd cheering the siblings name before the fight. This gives the PCs wanting to win without killing the final opponent and more talking while fighting. Both PC and NPC confused as the siblings meet.

1
lasalle202•

Per the Adventure Engineers https://youtu.be/lBIVtmbfqe0?list=PLY2GoZoifARXHPZ7CBuhJtG9ppZIEP-c2&t=302 Plot hooks are primarily designed for PLAYERs rather than CHARACTERs. Plot hooks for players will typically come in one of three styles:

  • Here We Come To Save The Day! - the Appeal to Heroism. The players / characters might want to do something because it is the right thing to do - save Timmy from the well, or prevent the zombies from overrunning Hobbittown. Also includes the twisted sister of balancing the scales of justice - REVENGE!
  • Gimme That Sweet Phat L00TZ! - the Appeal to Reward. The players / characters might want to do something because they get goodies for doing it - an actual cash reward; the chance to find and claim the Sword of Awesomeness that was lost in the tomb; but also things like land / a tower / a ship; a noble/religious/cultural title; or currying the favor of Important People.
  • The Bear Went Over the Mountain to See What He Could See - the Appeal to Discovery. This might be a typical Whodunit? crime mystery or finding out "Why are the Goblins giving out pet chickens to all the village children?" or "YES! I do want to see the Forest of Floating Trees!" or "I bet we can make it through the Lost Caves of Mystery", or "Is that old lady in the woods just an old lady in the woods, or is she an evil hag?"

The types of hooks you use should be tuned to the players at your table, but the more you can tie multiple Appeals into the hook, the more likely you are to draw the player's interest.

1
AlexD2003OP•

Nice this is super helpful

2