How does newjeans keep getting away with prerecorded live for like a year now.

Discussion

Like seriously? Even their awful super shy encore didnt even get any criticisms as much as their fellow company mates- Le Sserafim.

Lipsyncing is a genre should rly be applicable to HYBE atp but this one group particularly keeps getting away with it.

Posted Nov 20, 2023, 7:02 AM UTC · locked

4752
Kep1ersTelescope•

No hate to newjeans (or any of the other groups I'm going to mention), but it's genuinely fascinating how groups like aespa got a lot of negative attention for almost always lip syncing in their first years, or people said they weren't interested in IVE because they never sing live at music shows (this was before I am era), but with other groups like newjeans or le Sserafim it's very rarely a topic of discussion. Don't get me wrong, newjeans have sung live sometimes, but the vast majority of their performances have been pre recorded and it just... never comes up the way it did constantly come up when it was aespa.

I think it comes down to two factors:

  1. newjeans' songs aren't vocal based and don't have high notes or big vocal moments, so it's not as jarring to watch them lip sync, while Winter pretending to hit the high notes was memed to death because it's just weirder to watch.

  2. Newjeans are simply at the top of the world and untouchable right now, they are in the phase of their career where they hold the public in the palm of their hands.

189
lvnayeon•

If you mention something not so positive about them, you get ratioed. Aespa were crucified for months while we know what they’re capable of, it just SM for some reason doesn’t want. Till this day, I see comments about WY/Leeseo situation despite IVE being among the GG with most live performance.

80
92sn•

Its also because they have tons of hybe stans that defending them so hard. Also person above have said that because they on top now so they untouchable. Knetizens seeing them as rose tinted glasses. But how long this gonna happen? If they not improving, more new and talented gg coming, this whole untouchable from criticisms would eventually wear off.

44
No_Following_9705•

Definitely. They need to improve their singing as well as the fairy vocal r&b music. Bcz it will get repetitive after a certain time. It's just that after newjeans, no other gg had debuted from the big4. If baemon makes it through the ahyeon controversy, they will surely become the next IT group in kpop followed by the SM gg. This applies to all groups. Nobody remains untouchable for a very long time . BTS & blackpink are the only exception.

9
Kep1ersTelescope•

As a Dive I'm obviously biased, but it kills me that they got dragged for lip syncing that cover but when a few months later they sang I Am live at almost every music show performance no one noticed.

26
quick_sand08•

Okay but lsf also don't get criticized for lip syncing like aespa got. Aespa atleast shut everyone up with their amazing encore while lsf showed their mid vocals but still don't get criticsed.

23
ilivesoilove613•

In what world Lesserafim doesn’t get criticized for their vocals?

32
Kep1ersTelescope•

Le Sserafim got criticised for their vocals (mainly once after the unforgiven encore), but they don't get criticised for lipsyncing specifically. This post is about lip syncing and I have almost never seen them getting criticised for that.

12
No_Following_9705•

Lsf got dragged left & right for their unforgiven encore. Pannchoa posted back to back articles on lsf & called Sakura & kazuha tone deaf.

32
Overall-Ad5894•

Y’all need to be truthful. Literally every single Hybe group gets criticized for their vocals.

16
crimsonpaths•

There's a difference between generalized criticism and specific hate train

8

As a non-fan of either group, I've always found it interesting how Ive and NewJeans treatment differs. Ive gets absolute crucified for the same stuff NJ gets vehemently defended for.

89
No_Following_9705•

This! Even though IVE & NJ are more or less equally popular in South korea, the difference in their treatment baffles me. When one group does cute antics ,people love it . When the other group does the same, they get called 'pick me' . Poor leeseo has been through shit in spite of being a minor .PS- I AM NOT A FAN OF EITHER OF THEM.

34
crimsonpaths•

While Aespa was crucified and called queens "of lipsyncing.. It's safe to say KPop stans don't expect much from certain groups coz the bar is already low

37
shinonome-ena•

If hybe stans could more or less silence criticism for their inappropriate concepts, then this is basically nothing for them.

35
randomizedcat•

Other than Cookie, have they actually ever had other inappropriate concepts? I don't really follow them super closely, but I haven't noticed anything that seemed inappropriate after Cookie. And the discourse about that song was literally everywhere when it came out.

19
Melon13579•

Talent was never their selling point that’s it. It is not like their fans or the public cared.

28
Time_to_reflect•

…Let’s not persecute any group, though?

What’s up with that mentality of “oh this group is “getting away” with that thing, let’s all start criticising them”? If you don’t like how New Jeans sing, that’s what your post should be about, not about them not being hated enough.

Suffering olympics is not a good game to play.

25
92sn•

because they still knetizens n kpop stans fave groups. Watch once another gg rise that be another knetizens fave, they gonna start noticing more n more newjeans weakness. Seem like thats maybe why hybe still not sending them to perform LIVE at US tv shows.

24
No_Following_9705•

Baemon's debut will change the trajectory if they make it through the ahyeon controversy.

1
bgmlk•

You could count with the fingers on your one hand the amount of kpop groups who do actually sing live so this animosity against NJ is really interesting.

Not even going to get into that HYBE comment cause it’s hilarious 😂

23†

Yeah the HYBE comment is weird. It’s fine to talk about NewJeans specifically because I do think their backing tracks are quite loud and that’s fair to go into.

But HYBE is also BTS and Seventeen...have you seen Jungkook’s Golden promotions? Those mics are on.

31
bgmlk•

to me it sounds like they have something against HYBE artists in general and are using NJ as a scapegoat since the others have more established fandoms

13†
No_Following_9705•

Newjeans gets away with almost everything. Their producer min hee Jin who is rumoured to be pedo gets appreciated inspite of making problematic teasers (ETA controversy) If groups like IVE or lsf pull this, they'd get eaten alive.

22
ilivesoilove613•

I don’t understand the “getting away with it” part , like.. with not getting hate like other groups or what?

15†
92sn•

For example, for performance, knetizens usually would mainly mentioning their visual and avoid talking about their vocal while groups like aespa n ive got microanalyzed.

39
ilivesoilove613•

It’s giving “I believe that if x got hate for this, y should get hate too” so.. now we wait until knetz do their thing and even things out (?)

-1†

We just wondering why the double standards

27
ilivesoilove613•

If this was a post with points and criticism about their performance I would have even added my two cents on it. But is not, the double standard you say is probably the hate someone got that newjeans isn’t apparently getting and honestly before I get jumped for “defending”them, I’ll stop right here and leave you to find answers to that wonder you have

5†

Yup, that’s exactly what they mean

3†
Love-shot2018•

There’s been a lot of criticism about lip synching in regards to newer groups, especially when compared to previous gens. Personally, my expectations for music shows versus award shows are different.

If there’s a performance for an award show that is lip synched, I’ll skip and move along. Nothing more you can do.

11

I don’t think there’s anything to “get away” with??? most kpop groups are lip syncing these days and they definitely do get a lot of criticism

11†

For some reason Nj just doesn’t get as much criticism for lip-syncing as others groups do so op is wondering why

21

so op is upset that new jeans isn’t getting enough hate for their liking???

do you not see how strange this conversation is? none of these groups deserve to be crucified for something as simple as lip syncing.

4†

They aren’t upset they are just asking why people don’t care when it comes to nj but proceed to rip apart any other group for doing the exact same as them. You may not like it but it is legit question.

6†
sonaminnie•

lipsyncing in Korean music shows is ok imo because they have ungodly hours and r ecord multiple times but rearly?? even at a western award show which is prerecorded?? not ok. they should be able to sing live since it's 50% of their job and they will only improve by criticism *I do not condone any type of hate)

3†
ughbadbye•

love some of their songs but cant get into them because i haven’t seen them perform live with little to no backtracks

4†
AutoModeratorMOD•

Hey thinker! Great post up there. Make sure your post title is clear. One and two word titles are not allowed. Use paragraphs to make it easier to read. Please make sure to read the rules before posting. Mod applications are currently open! Apply here!

You can fill out our Feedback Form while you wait for some comments. Thank you and happy posting!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
AutoModeratorMOD•

Hello u/Jrstunn3r. Your contribution in r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Click here to find out more about karma and how to gain it. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
AutoModeratorMOD•

This post has been locked as it may potentially break our subreddit rules and is currently awaiting manual moderator review. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
chidi45gg enthusiast•

Simply because most people like me aren't here for the vocals but the songs🤷🏾‍♀️ and some for the aesthetic of their brand which is well co ordinated. I enjoy some of their performances and think they're fun but I never really cared if it was live or not as far as it sounds good on my headphones while walking around I'm good

-1†

How tf are people here apparently taking a very obvious, very low effort post by an anti seriously??? Why is this sub so fucking obvious in it's hated of newjeans that you're allowing a post of this low quality on here in the first place??

-1†
Mooseblood2d•

this is so HATE post.

-1†
badlyeye•

atp lipsyncing is to be expected when it comes to their performances that’s why no one gives a shit really.

-2†