r/piano•
PatchyCB

Advice on beginner piano purchase?

🙋Question/Help (Beginner)

Hiya Any advice would be super helpful, I'm a guitar player (played a bit of piano way back) looking to get into piano

So I'm looking to spend no more than £300 and I've been looking around and seen the 'Casio CDP-S110' is on sale on amazon for £269 and the 'CDP-S160' is on sale for £299 on casio's site and on paper I think they are both good? given 88 keys and weighted keys but I've read a lot of distain for them, so just curious whether that's a purists thing or warranted and if there are better options I could get for £300

I also saw there were some sales on brands like "MuStar" but I presumed brands like that are similar to guitar brands where if they aren't heard of they usually are worth staying away from

I know everyone usually recommends from what i've read the Roland FP-10 and Yamaha P45 but they are out of my price range currently!

Posted Nov 20, 2023, 9:48 PM UTC

26

The Roland FP-10 is currently £360 on Amazon.

I would recommend saving the extra £60 and going with that, the key action is unmatched in this price range. Ivory touch, triple sensors and escapement are features you won't find elsewhere at this price range. The sound engine is really good too, and models things like how open the piano lid is, and sympathetic resonance.

2
Bakuryu91•

OP, listen to this guy

2
ILoveKombucha•

Tough call. At a really low price point, I almost recommend to go midi-controller + software, assuming you have a decent (nothing fancy, but not old junk either) computer (big assumption on my part). The action will not be what you would want for serious piano playing... but to learn the basics of playing keyboard, I think it's fine.

You could buy something like a Nektar SE49 midi controller for less than 100 bucks (USD), and then buy Pianoteq software (the lowest tier, called "Stage") for 140 (USD) (you can demo the software before you buy, by the way).

You can kind of start learning the basics on anything, as long as it has full size keys. Just don't expect to play serious piano repertoire on un-weighted keys; it's very difficult and not fun to do so. You just need too much control for anything but weighted IMO (some people do it, though!).

But it'll be a long time before you are even needing to think about that.

In an ideal world, though, I'd start on a KAwai ES110. Great piano. Sub 1000 USD last I checked. Yamaha P45 is a fine choice, too.

1
Tyrnis•

I have only played on the CDP-S100 and S150 (slightly older models than the S110/160) -- they were definitely budget instruments, and not as nice as the Yamaha P-45, but they were still okay. I would pick a CDP model over a no-name brand, and definitely over not having an instrument at all.

Basically: if that's what you can afford, and it's not feasible to save up more for a Yamaha / Roland, then go for it.

1

I recommend you should go with the P-45 👌

1
_quantum_girl_•

Buy a second hand Yamaha P45. I got mine for 300 euro. I don't regret it.

1