WoK death rattle question

SpoilerCosmere (no TSM/SP4)

“Ten people, with Shardblades alight, standing before a wall of black and white and red. ”

— Collected on Jesachev 1173, 12 seconds pre-death, by the Silent Gatherers. Subject an ardent member of the the Silent Gatherers, overheard during his last moments.

From WoK, Chapter 9, "Damnation

Most people seem to take this to be about the battle of Thaylen Field at the end of Oathbringer. The ten people being the Radiants and heralds present at the event, including Venli.

But here is the thing; we didn't see a "...wall of black and white and red.". The Everstorm is black with red lightning lighting it from within, but never described as white, so it , or its stormwall doesn't fit. The Thrill manifested as a red mist or cloud with scenes of battle playing out in its shapes, but again, no white or red. Odium's power is described as golden, so it can't be taken in combination with that. Dalinar's Perpendicularity is white, but the ten people were never "before" it, and it was in opposition to the other forces on the field so it seems unlikely to fit. The city wall perhaps? Maybe, but again i don't remember it being described that way.

Now, we do know a situation were powers associated with the colors black, white and red converge; Scadrial, in the conflict between Harmony and Autonomy. Black for Ruin, white for Preservation and red for Autonomy. Now, we don't know it red truly is associated with the power of Autonomy - red seems to be the result of corrupted investiture, and is seen both on Roshar and Scadiral, e.g. in the red eyes of the Voidbringers and the Kandra serving Trell, serving Autonomy. But given the Ghostbloods' involvement on Roshar and Harmony's state at the end of the Lost Metal... well, im starting get really worried about Sazed.

Posted Nov 22, 2023, 9:36 PM UTC

3711
SixStrungKing•

I genuinely believe the wall of Black, white and Red was the marbling on the Parshendi Odium brought to witness the battle.

More than that, the White could very well be the Skybreakers.

70
ColdButCozyOP•

possible, but i don't think it is likely. Neither the Parsh nor the Skybreakers did more than watch then run away, except Szeth who would be counted among the ten people, and a few Fused(the Flowing One who Dalinar sent Lyft after and the Heavenly Ones Szeth killed with Nightblood). That also leaves Nale as the only other Skybreaker on the field, not to mention that the Skybreakers aren't ever really associated with white, except Szeth. Their associated stone is a smokestone, their uniforms are whatever the local law-enforcement uniform is, with Nale most often seen in the dark Azish uniform. Their Spren appear as dark rifts in space.

It could, i guess be a metaphor for the broader conflict with the ten people being the ten orders fighting against the Parsh, but again that doesnt fit as the Skybreakers fight, if not for Odium, then alongside the Parsh, against the other orders.

-2
BlessedOfStorms•

I agree with you about it not being the battle of thaylen field.

However, I totally agree with the other commentor on the wall of black and red and white. That is, IMO, absolutely referring to a parsh army and their marbling.

I don't think the rattle referenced the battle of thaylen field, though, because we certainly did not have 10 people with shardblades alight. Kal, shal, Ren, Jas, had shardblades alight. Dal, tal, ash, ven, szeth did not. Lift had a shard rod.

I'm assuming this references a still unread event.

38
GaiusOctavianAlerae:truthwatchers: Truthwatcher•

It could just be a reference to past desolations and a hint about who the voidbringers were

14
BlessedOfStorms•

I think the death rattles are all scenes of the future granted by Moelach. I could be wrong, but that's what I remember them being.

6
Lemerney2•

The predominant theory is that it's the Heralds fighting the Singers, as they're ten people with glowing shardblades, fighting against a wall of marbled Singer carapace.

4
KevanKnowsBest•

Cant be. The death rattles are visions of the future and one of the heralds is dead

8
Lemerney2•

They don't have to be visions of the future, necessarily. We see others that are likely about the past. However, if they are, that either means that the herald replacement theory is true, or a moment with the ten viewpoints fighting a Parsh army is in the future.

2
KevanKnowsBest•

I think its the latter imho. However, Kaladin doesnt want to fight the parshendi so idk how thatll work out

1
Icarus-Orion-007:elsecallers: Elsecaller•

Interesting theory!

I think it’s referring to the Parshmen. I always though it was referring to the heralds too.

3
Chimalli-•

There's a lot left of to interpretatiom with some of these. Especially, because Sanderson only had an outline at the time of writing the death rattles. But, as far as the colors go:

Daliar's perpendicularity is White Everstorm is Black The Thrill is Red

1
SheevMillerBand:truthwatchers: Truthwatcher•

Just seems like a metaphor for the ten orders against the singers to me.

1