Shut up and let an old man rant for a while...
Posted Feb 7, 2013, 6:24 AM UTC
Posted Feb 7, 2013, 6:24 AM UTC
i blame AOL floppies.
You are my doppelganger from another land. I remember those days fondly - no mouse, text menus, the grunt of a 286 "smart terminal" which booted from a 720k floppy, networks that ran at a whopping 2.5 megabits per second, dip switches - those were the days.
High 5 for the memories.
If you treat people like idiots, they eventually become them.
"And if you gaze for long into an abyss, the abyss gazes also into you".
Nietzsche said it as well.
THIS. I really don't think of my users as "those guys" they understand their job and only occasionally break something i have to look into. If things were harder. Do you think users would be more able to handle it? No, they'd complain it's too hard and want something else, and you'd have to teach them how to use it! Intuitive isn't a curse, it just means that instead of constant pestering you over how to press F6 for the kajillionth time this week, they know that if they click the button, it just works.
Is that really so bad?
It's when they understand their job so pitifully that it takes less than ten minutes of study to become better at it than they are after ten years. It's when they suddenly forget one day how to do the same thing they've been doing their entire career. It's when they forget how to spell their own name. It's when they somehow can't read instructions on the screen in front of them in 48-point text which have been tested for clarity with preschoolers.
It's when their bosses hear of these examples of breathtaking incompetence and can't see anything wrong with it. It's when you are given so little respect, and your time so little value, that people demand you drive two hours to their location to press the "ON" button for them because they can't be bothered to literally lift a single finger to do their damn jobs when they can make you do it for them.
Oh, and they make six figures a year doing... well, apparently not anything involving actual work. That's what you're for.
Is that really so bad?
Okay, different user type entirely. These users don't want anything to change ever, they already hate that they have to use the computer, and in some strange political protest refuse to learn it.
I am just so glad none of my coworkers here are that ignorant.
It's when they understand their job so pitifully that it takes less than ten minutes of study to become better at it than they are after ten years
This is the most frightening thing I've learned in all my years of doing IT... I can learn your job in a week... and in a month I would be doing it better than you.
...or worse... in most cases... I can automate your job and eliminate your position all together.
Been there, done that. The worst ones are where the position turns out to have been completely unnecessary in the first place - it doesn't even need automating, because it literally produces nothing of value, or it addresses a need which can be eliminated entirely with a little thought.
I've run into places where more than a million dollars a year was being spent doing the equivalent of continually mopping the floor because they'd built under a waterfall and hadn't closed the skylight.
The problem is that now a lot of people think they're very computer savvy, put that in their resume and get hired, but freeze instantly when a button has changed its color or placement after an update, or if if a text box with an easy to read and understand error message pops up. Think about people that are able to upload a picture in facebook, but freak out when they have to do the same with their companies custom upload form.
Oh trust me, I understand. The person who hired me kept telling me that every single other person she interviewed for the position (which requires php knowledge) kept saying how they could mod a template...
So yeah.
How many keyboard shortcuts do you know right now? It doesn't matter... like almost everything else Microsoft unstandardized them all... because they are either evil or incompetent... I have to assume evil.
Microsoft has been years trying to work consistent keyboard shortcuts into its own products from their disparate histories. The worst one that remains seems to be the forward/find discrepancy between Outlook and everything else, not sure how they can ever get that sorted.
Still evil though. So evil.
Lotus Notes showed me how bad it could get. Their shortcut functions are completely alien to me when I was using it. I'd try to reply to all and end up in settings.
[...] the thing they shouldn't be doing in the first place can't possibly work because they should never need to do that if they knew what they were doing in the first place.
I want this on a T-shirt. Now.
Come on, when the PC came out, the users didn't know anything.
They didn't know punched cards, or fortran, or vm or unix or how to use a hard copy terminal, or ANYTHING. And they could do only run one program at a time (until sidekick).
Ha! Nice... I worked for the company that produced Sidekick.
but it also helps to have an AST 6 pack plus.
428 or so keyboard shortcuts, and I learn new ones every few days when I encounter them. That's at age 25. By the time I'm your age (I'm guessing about 40?) I expect to know about a thousand, since I'm expecting to run out of shortcuts. On the other hand, I should also know about 90% of the command prompt/dos commands by then.
That's an oddly specific number?
Ran it through my head quickly. There's probably more I know but missed. I'm pretty good at maths, which is why subnetting's a pretty easy subject for me :D
[deleted]
I've been saying the populace is two decades behind the technology, but marketing pushes it through by giving best case scenarios and stupid buzz-words.
It's not "the cloud" it's "a remote server". Christ people.
As far as keyboard shortcuts, I've taken to creating my own. Helps me, but not the rest of society.
Just in the past couple weeks, I've had several people come up to me and ask "So what exactly is this 'cloud' that we're supposed to save stuff to now?" They're smart enough to know it's not a fluffy white thing in the sky, but they also don't understand what a server is.
I also still get people who think that their email is only accessible from their own private computer, even though they get it on their phones as well. I think it's great that we're moving more towards a cloud-based infrastructure for certain things (though I still prefer my local copy, because the internet does go out occasionally), but we get all these people who jump at exciting key words like "the cloud" and get all into it without actually understanding what it is. And once it's on the internet, it's always there.
I prefer local copies because I don't want anyone else to control the stuff I can access.
Those buzzwords make me cringe. Business speak is such bullshit.
Amen brother ivanmarsh - it's 18 years as tech support for me, and the people are undoubtedly supporting the plot of the movie Idiocracy. I'm seeing it happen first hand!
I swear there was a life pro tip a while back that reintroduced the concept of "holding down the control button and pushing c will copy text." I'm a magician for knowing ctrl z and y.
Most of all I miss ctrl-shift-f7. Life in the humanities was so much easier with a double indent that I didn't have to program or use the mouse to configure.
It's like you wrote down years of my own frustrations!
If you care about Reddit Gold, I would happily gift you a month just for this.
I was afraid getting into IT was going to be a bad choice in the long run, because I figured the kids are going to grow up with this stuff, and they'll be able to support each other. More and more evidence everyday that they have no clue of the how or why the PC or applications they use EVERYDAY actually operate.
I've come to the same conclusion as you when it comes to dumbing down GUIs. It seems like a cycle with every new product. At first it requires new skills from the users, and they will acquire them. But to broaden the userbase, companies will try make the interface easier and easier to use, often even remove functionality that could disturb less tech savvy people. The new users think they don't need to know anything about how the software/hardware works, and are completely helpless when something out of the ordinary happens, or they have to do something new.
I'm also on board with the theory that the new generation, while using IT more than any generation before, is in fact less tech savvy. The majority knows how to make a phone call, post something on facebook or watch a youtube video, but that's about it. Anything that goes beyond the pure basics, and they're lost. It's not that they couldn't learn how to do more, but even doing a google search to find a solution seems to much effort for many.
Not every car owner/driver is a car mechanic. But car mechanics who grew up in a time when everyone could pump their own gas and change their own tires might get a bit annoyed if they had to contend with 400 "How do I start my car again?" questions every Monday morning.
I haven't even thought about repairing. More along the lines of your example. It's about knowing how to use the device and software you have to deal with every day. E.g., knowing, that if a text box pops up, you should read it. Or how to open/close a program, even if it's a new one.
[deleted]
Same, same, same. Me and my other IT friend argue about this all the time. I am on your side.
However, he argues that this has always been the case, the example he likes to use is:
You have a community of cavemen, fire is their most advanced technology. Do you think everyone in the community knows how to start a fire or do you think its more likely that one person or group of people, who sit around bitching at night about how people only come and cook shit on the fire, YET THEY HAVE NO IDEA HOW IT EVEN WORKS!!!
It's when the clan chiefs think that this fire thing is great, but they can't be bothered to learn how to produce it themselves, and can't really understand how the same thing can cook food, provide warmth, AND be used to scare off predators. This misunderstanding means they also can't figure out where the fire goes every day when they wash it in the river, nor why it takes you so long to bring it back to the bits of tree they so generously washed for you.
Not to mention that they read something once in a trade mammoth and now they think fire should also be used for decoration because it's shiny and flickery, and how dare you tell them, the chiefs, that this is a stupid idea and would burn both them and the cave. After all, you're just the Fire Peon, what would you know. And then it's your fault when they burn themselves.
At this point, you find yourself very calmly trying to remember exactly why it would be bad for the chiefs to mysteriously be turned to charcoal one night by the, uh... river gods.
You and your response are awesome.
This man speaks the truth. I wonder if this is how the automobile enthusiasts hand building cars on their own felt when the Model T started getting churned out and any idiot could buy a car.
This being r/talesfromtechsupport, I believe I might get downvoted, but I still want to comment on this.
Having users who are incompetent at using computers is not something I would rant about. Sure, we post stories about technologically challenged people who happen to put themselves into what we find to be comedic situations, or rant about getting some sort of abuse from prepotent users whose tiny bit of power makes them believe they can do such thing. With all due respect, you seem to be ranting about doing your job.
I did IT for a while a few years back, and yes, it is frustrating. Keep in mind, however, that people don't HAVE to or NEED to know how to make things work. Sure, they could google a couple things and that would make your life easier. But then you'd probably be out of a job, wouldn't you? I feel like IT people have some sort of sense of superiority saying stuff like "Sweet lord, that person is SO stupid, they don't even know how to do the things I actually GET PAID to help them do!"
...people that hold the title of vice president and above that don't know how to operate their fucking e-mail application
So...? Maybe what they do is vital for the company you work for to make a profit, from which your salary comes. You don't need to know what they do, but you would very likely flip shit if your paycheck didn't come, wouldn't you? I think the IT life can turn you bitter, again, been there, done that. Now that I've moved on, I realize that I looked at those people though my tiny IT scope, thinking they were all idiots for not knowing how to configure their Outlook, or how to access a shared folder on a network computer... They're not idiots. They are most likely smart and perfectly capable ON WHAT THEY ACTUALLY DO.
With all due respect, you seem to be ranting about doing your job.
It is not the job of IT people to make up for a fundamental lack of skills that people advertised themselves as having to get the very job they are doing.
But then you'd probably be out of a job, wouldn't you?
No... I'd be able to concentrate on the bigger picture items I don't have time for because I'm having to hand-hold someone through the basic operation of something as stupid as an e-mail client.
Suggesting I'm complaining about doing my job here is the equivalent of you thinking your auto mechanic should spend all his time adjusting your rear-view mirror for you when he should be working on fixing your transmission.
Suggesting I'm complaining about doing my job here is the equivalent of you thinking your auto mechanic should spend all his time adjusting your rear-view mirror for you when he should be working on fixing your transmission.
I don't understand. Is this something auto-mechanics aren't supposed to do or something?
I keep having to get my mechanic friends to help me with my seat. I don't understand these electric seats, but I have one, so I have to use it. I had one in my '89 Buick, too, and I learned that one pretty good, but this ones different.
This one has, like, three up/down buttons, and this little joystick thingy on the side, and to make it do what you want you have to press all these buttons and move the little joystick around. I tried to do adjust it once, but I got it all messed up, and I was leaning backwards into the back seat, so, yeah.
My daughter is a pretty good mechanic, so usually I have her do it, but she's away at college, so now I just take it into the shop. They used to try to teach me, but I always ended up messing it up, and they get frustrated, so now they just do it for me.
Once I accidentally pressed this button on my dash as well. All of the sudden, both blinkers started blinking! I didn't know what to do, and I didn't want to mess it up, so I brought it to the shop and they helped me. Those guys are really good with cars.
I'm not sure if this is supposed to be serious or not... but I guess if you have the money to throw away to have a mechanic adjust your seat for you while fluids spill out of the bottom of your vehicle and you think the seats are more important then more power to you.
Exactly my point.
These companies are spending a decent amount of money paying IT personell to basically show users how to change their personal preferences. The things IT people do sometimes are tantamount to adjusting a users seat.
The above isn't true. I'm no mechanic, but I can certainly change out an alternator or water pump. I'm also not in IT. I am, however, decent with computers, and I know how terrible terrible and helpless users can be.
When people like the person you replied to above, complain about posts like yours, they don't seem to realize that you are, in fact, similar to a mechanic dealing with a customer like I pretended to be above.
Suggesting I'm complaining about doing my job here is the equivalent of you thinking your auto mechanic should spend all his time adjusting your rear-view mirror for you when he should be working on fixing your transmission.
Well, I guess it depends on the level of incompetence displayed by the user and/or their inability/unwillingness to do the smallest amount of research. Again, I think those are some of the things we actually make fun of in here, not rant about. Might just be me. I'm seriously not trying to be a douche or anything, I just happen to believe some of those things come with the job, and that there's surely some people who don't know rear view mirrors need manual adjustment.
I don't think you're trying to be a douche... I hear what you're saying. I hope I didn't give you the impression I thought you were a douche.
I would very much every day of my job like to at least try to give the average end-user the benefit of the doubt. But every day that gets harder and harder as it's beaten out of me.
"Special users" is a term that has come about from IT people. "Special Users" are those users that take up 80% of your time dealing with the same issues over and over again. The pool of "special users" is getting larger and larger. That's not entirely their fault. That is also caused by IT departments being spread so thin we don't have the time or resources to dedicate to anything to our satisfaction. I don't think anything I've done in the last five years or more has been done well enough to stand up to the standards I would like them to.
For the record... I'm quitting my job next month... to be unemployed. I'm moving to another state and looking for work rather than deal with the people I'm currently working with any more.
I know more keyboard shortcuts than most, to the point that i only use my mouse a few times an hour - at my secondary school, punks kept on nicking the mice, so you had to make do without.
The problem is hyperspecialization, and proliferation of technology to the masses.
People today... With interfaces becoming more "Let us do this for you, you poor simple thing" and less "Figure it out, you work this way because it's more efficient"... People are told what to do, where to click - Having to figure out nothing for one's self, you are instructed into stupidity. Something like catching a man's fish for him, instead of teaching him how to fish.
When computers were more rare, it was more likely an intelligent person was at the helm, not the simple worker or minimum wager.... Now-a-days, it's every peon with a mouse and keyboard in hand. People who can't operate a map, people who don't know or care what the other buttons on their TV remote do. It's not the smart people, the people who got their job for their skill and ability working with computers, it's everybody. From the top 5% of brainiacs to the top 5% of the morons.
And lastly, don't forget - For each technician who earns their wings, a better idiot is produced.
I'm 24 and I'm already sliding towards these kind of rants. We are breeding techno-numpties.
We're breeding job security IMO ;)
Not for any job we'd want.
I'm 17 and I already have rants like this. But, the "User Friendly" interfaces cough Metro cough are making it harder and harder for us competant folk to use them. When I press the start key, I want a start menu, not a fucking start screen with buttons designed for tablets, and new names for everything.
I hate the new Metro UI. I will never upgrade to Windows 8.
That's why I'm happy Apple hasn't forcibly grafted iOS onto OS X. There's a few bits here and there, but ultimately it's still a desktop OS and my Mac Mini behaves like a traditional desktop. And of course, KDE is still touch-free as of the moment for my Linux boxes.
Heh. It's not like they can force me to stop using windows 7, vista, or xp. Long live the mouse! And keyboard shortcuts.