r/Guitar•
Rusty_M

[QUESTION] How to tell if I don't like a guitar or if it just needs a setup

QUESTION

Next month I'll be buying my first electric in over 20 years. I'm looking forward to getting back on the horse. Currently I only have a somewhat neglected Squier Jagmaster from 2000 and a Fender Roc Pro 1000 that probably needs all new pots. I plan to replace both of these. The amp with a Fender Mustang GTX 100 and the guitar is as yet undecided. The existing equipment I will use as projects to learn how to tinker (replace pots, pickups, tuners etc.)

When trying some guitars in shops, I noticed at least one had significant fret buzz. I plan on learning to set neck relief, intonation, string height this time and do things right, but I don't yet know how to check out a guitar, see an issue and ascertain whether these things are the cause or whether it needs work by a professional.

So far, after only visiting a shop once, the shortlist is:

  • Some form of Ibanez Jem - probably the 77P, though I could only try the JR and quite liked it.
  • Ibanez SML721 - I was intimidated by the fanned frets, but my wife thrust it into my hands and I had a good time
  • Epiphone Alex Lifeson Les Paul Custom Axcess - Not tried yet, but I love the apparent versatility and video reviews certainly sound good. I could be swayed by the fact I do like the artist.

This could grow or shrink as I try guitars. The only things I really know so far is I'd like a lot of versatility, and I'm pretty sure I want a humbucker at the bridge at the very least.

Posted Nov 24, 2023, 8:34 AM UTC

12
a1b2t•

you need to figure out and isolate what you like, no theres no "a lot of versatility" no guitar truely does everything.

do you want a wide flat neck, thin, what kind of sounds are you trying to achieve?

like an inbetween fender/superstrat would be a charvel, if that is what you are going for. but it wont be a fender and wont be the same as a jackson.

1
Rusty_MOP•

Thanks. I'm not sure on neck thicknesses, but it's looking so far like I like thinner necks. I certainly liked the feeling of the Ibanezes I tried more than I did the Epi Les Pauls.

1