I know this isn't /r/adblock but what are some /r/torrent related sites you have guys have whitelisted?
Posted Feb 7, 2013, 6:04 PM UTC
Posted Feb 7, 2013, 6:04 PM UTC
Most private trackers don't have any ads. The only private tracker I know has ads is TL.
You shouldn't whitelist ads on torrent sites. Block those ads. They're making money off of other people's copyrights. I don't believe file sharing is wrong, but I do believe profiting from it is wrong.
What about general searching on these sites? No single file is responsible for ads. Would adds work say on the landing page? But no ads on any file page?
People only come to the landing page because the search will result in the copyrighted files they seek. For a torrent site to earn profit from any part of their site seems wrong to me.
On the other hand, an entirely non-profit organization running a torrent site could hardly be seen as anything other than the next evolution of the concept of the free public library.
But that distinction is not ever made because all mainstream public file sharing sites are hugely profit-driven and are quite correctly characterized as commercial piracy organizations.
I think we could make some real progress in the file sharing world if someone made a torrent site that operated as a legit non-profit.
It would almost certainly still be illegal, but it would inspire some much more focused and interesting debate over the morality of file sharing once all the profit motive is removed from it at every level.
So perhaps a non profit that maintains a torrent of trackers? Users can download a zip of trackers and be off to the races. Very low bandwidth for the non profit
Even if piratebay went non-profit and removed all ads that'd be good enough for me. Registering as a non-profit for the regular financial audits would be necessary too, to prove compliance with non-profit organization law (like what Wikipedia does).
But no one will do it because running a torrent site is illegal whether you make profit off it or not. It'd be a nice way to make a statement, but it would require financial martyrdom. Even without profit, it may even be criminal in US law.
I can't think of any private trackers that have ads...
I can :P
Torrentleech > screenshot
TheAudioScene > screenshot
Empornium > screenshot
I'm sure out of the hundreds and hundreds of trackers I've perused I could find some more, I seem to remember there being a few others at least :)