Calories Reduced While Trying to Gain Weight

App Question

I like MacroFactor very much. It’s been very useful to me as I try to gain weight and muscle. I have a hard time gaining weight, I naturally want to eat less than what I probably should. With MacroFactor’s help I successfully added about 7 pounds, but I’ve been stalled out for several months now.

The part I don’t understand is the goal strategy part of the app. Every week I check in and it usually keeps my macros/calories flat or drops them a little. Every week it seems to go down by a little bit. This week it went down by another 26 calories.

I’m trying to understand why it keeps dropping my calorie requirements when I haven’t gained any real weight in several months. I feel like I should probably be eating more and I don’t understand why the app wants me to eat less.

I’m probably doing something wrong, but I’m not sure how to fix it.

Posted Nov 27, 2023, 4:39 PM UTC

15
eric_twingethis is my flair•

First you need to show us what you're doing instead of making us guess.

You'll need to post screen shots of your expenditure page, trend weight page, and nutrition page.

4
AutoModeratorMOD•

Hello! This automated message was triggered by some keywords in your post.

It may be useful to check our FAQs which have an in-depth knowledge base article on why your macros might not add up to total calories, and whether to aim for your calorie or macro targets.

If that doesn't sound helpful, please disregard this message.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
at_root•

The app uses your trend weight and compares it to your goal. Doesn't really matter what if you're bulking/cutting/maintaining, if your weight trend (note: not actual weight) is not what your goal is then it will adjust. So if you're weight trend is +2lbs a month and your goal is 1lb per month, it will lower your calories.

Macrofactor relies on good data, are you logging your weight often and under the same circumstances? For example, I log my weight every morning as soon as I get out of bed but after I use the washroom.

1
MacroFactor-ModTeamMOD•

If you'd like to ask a question about changes to your energy expenditure estimate or nutrition recommendations from the app, please provide screenshots with all of the following information:

  1. Your weight trend for the past month. Scroll down a bit for the screenshot so "Change Rate" and "Energy Insight" are visible
  2. Your expenditure for the past month.
  3. Your current goal (maintenance, or target rate of weight gain/loss)
  4. Your nutrition for the past month

You can embed the screenshots in your post, or just link them in a comment. Whatever's most convenient for you.

Alternatively, you can submit an in-app ticket so that we can provide better assistance. In some cases, we may not be able to help on Reddit without you submitting an in-app ticket.

1
spottie_ottie•

So you're not gaining weight AND it keeps lowering your calorie target? That doesn't seem possible, let's see your weight trend and expenditure with target line.

1