Help me decide!

Question

Hi all,

I've recently started playing and for good I'm fixed on rivendell with numenor. From what I can gather my local scene is very good Vs evil format focused. I already play a lot of other mini-games so want to keep MEBSG as a side hustle. With that in mind I want to play a low model count evil faction. I've narrowed it down to (but am open to suggestions):

  • Rise of the necromancer LL

  • Dark riders

I've always enjoy hero hammer and nothing evil seems to come close outside of these.

I'm also stuck on which models to get. I'm tempted to get the named Nazgûl and convert them to represent the Dol Guldur. Is this something you think most TOs would be accepting of? I don't want to drop loads and then not be able to play them.

Please help! As I said I'm open to suggestions of other factions or lists but I'd like them to be playable at any points.

Posted Nov 28, 2023, 6:35 PM UTC

1212
METALLIC579•

If you want to have a better play experience for both you and your opponent I’d recommend Rise of the Necromancer LL.

If you’re looking to be more competitive and don’t care about your opponent’s play experience the Black Riders LL is the choice.

In terms of theme I love the Black Riders personally.

7
willmaster8OP•

Is the issue with black riders the cheesy way to auto win missions or am I missing something else about them?

2
MrSparkle92•

They were nerfed to remove the literally auto-win possibilities they had (they can no longer kill themselves to end the game turn 1), but they are still a very polarizing army. There are many situations where they will be projected to either win hard or lose hard simply because of the matchup.

7
METALLIC579•

The way the army plays feels like it changes the fundamentals of the game in a way. You have access to up to 9 strong Magic Casters and up to a -3 terror bubble. If your community is big into competitive play I’d say the Black Riders LL is a good list to get some experience playing against it.

If you’re more into just casual play the Black Riders can feel miserable to play against if played optimally.

Can the Black Riders LL be played in a casual environment? Of course… but if it is not played optimally it will probably feel bad for you, the Black Rider player, as well.

4
AdFabulous4876•

Black Riders for me, they are more impactful compared to the rise of the necromancer versions

5
bertrex151•

Ive never seen a problem with the nazgul and dolgulder models from a TO standpoint, as long as theres a way to tell them apart its fine. Both armies are pretty much the same models just different abilities.

3
Tedopolis•

both of these are unlikely to make you many friends, just played in a tournament last weekend where my opponent had done this conversion and they looked awesome. I have loved seeing some people make their own version of an evil fellowship if you love the herohammer side, which will be a better experience for your opponent

2
willmaster8OP•

Evil fellowship sounds like it might be my jam. What have people taken in the past?

1
Tedopolis•

Amdur, gothmog and a ringwraith are the most common, a khandish chieftain, suladan and mahud king are also lots of fun

1
Maultaschtyrann•

While your ideas are very good and both sound like good options, i would wanna throw another one into the mix: Sauron with a handful of orcs to fill up the leftover points. Sauron himself costs 400 points. Then you'd only need some second hand orcs, that you get for really low price on ebay and one commando pack. The commando pack would mean a captain and a banner-bearer, which both could be converted too.

Since this army is basically Sauron and filler for the remaining points, you dont need too many models and they can be obtained very cheaply. I think it's not among the most competitve armies, but it is themey like fuck and seeing Sauron on the board is something everyone, i know, is always happy about.

2
Rob775533•

Necromancer will be much more forgiving, as you can resurrect wraiths, but the black riders would be my choice, mostly because I think the minis are cooler & nostalgia for the movies.

1
Buckcon•

Just to throw in the option there is also the 3 trolls faction from the Hobbit!

You get 3 monsterous heroes and a cool campfire rule!

1
willmaster8OP•

I do like the trolls but there's no flexibility at all. 400 points, no green allies means at least one other faction. I'm a massive butterfly and a stickler for theme so I'd end up going deep into something else. I'd like to avoid that

2
Zanyo•

Riders for sure but can lead to a very poor experience for your opponent so I'd be letting them know before hand what they are in for.

1
Bitmarck•

I did play a few times against an Angmar list that was Buhdur and just a bunch of Cavetrolls. Its very elite, all monsters and pretty capeable in its own way. You don't have a lot of Might, Will or Fate, but you do have a lot of trolls with three attacks each and a decently high fight value.

1