Does it make sense to buy out my hot water tank now?
So with Reliance changing how they bill recently, it brought to light how much I'm paying to rent my hot water tank. But after running the numbers, I'm not sure if it makes financial sense to buy it out?
My current tank was installed in 2019, and my contract runs until July 2026, so I have about 32 payments at ~$25 each left. I will end up paying $800 in that time period if I stay. Total cost of the contract is ~$2100.
They tell me that I'll need to pay $1200+tax to buy out. I don't think that amount changes based on when in the contract I buy out, so it's not going to reduce with time. So already I'm spending more to buy out the contract than I would to keep renting, and I would lose the maintenance/repair support that comes with the rental.
Of course, the idea is that I'll save money in the long run, as I won't be paying rental fees after the buyout. Natural gas tanks like mine apparently last 8 to 12 years, mine is 4 years old, so I'd be spending $1200 for a tank that has 4 to 8 years of life left. My averaged monthly ownership cost would finally dip below the rental cost in July 2028, so the tank would need to last at least 9 years, and require zero maintenance for me to break even, as of today.
Alternatively, I keep renting it for the rest of my contract, and then replace it with a brand new one when I switch to month to month. I'm paying less to rent it to 2026, and I'd get a brand new tank at that point.
I'm leaning towards the latter option, or am I missing some part of this equation?
Posted Nov 29, 2023, 3:44 PM UTC
If your home is located in an area of Ontario where natural gas is not distributed by Enbridge, Inc. you can elect to cancel the contract [paying not more than $40 Rental Agreement Termination Charge + $125 pick-up charge (including draining and disconnection by Reliance) + pro-rated outstanding rental fees + HST] under the protection of the Competition Tribunal CT-2012-002 Consent Agreement.
You can then have a new ‘owned’ unit installed.
If you are within an ‘Enbridge’ area, the above agreement does not apply.
Thanks for the info. I'm in Ottawa, and previously my reliance bill was included in my Enbridge bill. Now it's a separate bill.
Do you know why me being in an Enbridge area means I can't cancel my contract as you described? It seems odd that my "Enbridge status" affects my contract with Reliance.
Paragraph 9 limits application to the ‘Relevant Market’, defined as
x. “Relevant Market” means the supply of water heaters and related services, including installation, maintenance, repair and disconnection services, to residential consumers in the local markets of Ontario where natural gas is not distributed by Enbridge, Inc.;
It is aimed at restricting Reliance anti-competitive contract terms... and sadly Enbridge was considered a large enough competition.
Paragraph 9. limits application to the ‘Relevant Market’ defined as;
It was enacted to restrict Reliance anti-competitive terms, and sadly the existence of Enbridge was considered sufficient competition.
You may still cancel under the terms of your contract, but Reliance will add an exorbitant ‘Early Termination Fee’.