Pumpkin candy help! Subbing calcium hydroxide with calcium chloride?

Hey there, hope I’m asking in the right place! My family makes a pumpkin candy that uses pickling lime for crunch before cooking the pieces in syrup to candy. Dosing for this candy for 2lbs pumpkin is 3/4oz slaked lime into ~7 3/4 US cups water.

Once rinsed of the line brine and summarily cooked in the syrup, The candy is then stored in this syrup in the fridge.

My question: the slices are stored in a brine of calcium hydroxide overnight so that they get crunchy, and then rinsed of the brine the next day before the candy. Can I sub in calcium chloride? How?

Posted Nov 29, 2023, 5:28 PM UTC

38
Spock_Drop-n-Roll•

Those are chemically not close. One is a salt and one is a base. They will not give you the same effect.

2
sonofsqueegeeOP•

So I can’t use calcium chloride for crispiness? I have read that people use this for crunch like the pickling lime in the recipe

1
TungstenChef•

With pickles, the calcium ion in the calcium chloride reinforces either the pectin or the cellulose structure in the vegetables (I have heard it stated both ways from what I would consider reliable sources.) Neither of these substances are likely to be in your candy, and it sounds like it's an entirely different chemical reaction taking place that depends on the presence of a strong base. I would try asking over at r/foodscience, there will probably be somebody over there with expertise in this sort of thing.

1
sonofsqueegeeOP•

Yup, It’s not candy at that time yet, it’s cut pieces of pumpkin. Like squash. It gets pickled in the slaked lime to be crunchy, and then rinsed off and then cooked in sugar syrup. It doesn’t start off as candy, it’s literally pumpkin. But I can ask over there

1
TungstenChef•

Gotcha, I was imagining some sort of pumpkin-flavored hard candy. In that case, both the calcium ions and the strong base provided by the hydroxide ions might be playing a part. That sub is still the best place to ask a question like that, I recommend you include as much information as possible about your process.

1
Spock_Drop-n-Roll•

The hydroxide will change the pH of the food. It needs to be washed off for safety. (Too high pH = botulism risk.) Calcium is the crisping factor. However, you should not deviate from safe canning methods. If you want to use calcium chloride you need to find a safe recipe using that.

1
sonofsqueegeeOP•

This is a very old recipe, and so all the versions call for slaked lime but specifically mention it for making the pumpkin crispy and that alone, before rinsing and cooking in sugar to candy the pumpkin. The result is crispy pumpkin slices that are sweet. This is not meant to be canned. There isn’t a recipe for this that uses calcium chloride that I can find, and yet I keep finding footnotes that state that either can be used for this purpose, but I have yet to find any evidence or recipes containing the calcium chloride recommended dosage, but also don’t know what I don’t know I guess. Maybe if that’s not enough to go on, I’ll see what the others a the food science sub think. Thanks for the effort and cheers

1
Spock_Drop-n-Roll•

You should be able to sub ~1:1.5 Ca(OH)2:CaCl2 for the calcium content. The calcium is the crisping agent here. Since you're not canning, I think there's some wiggle in trying new things. I would just note that CaCl2 is salty af, so I would also follow the washing process or your candy may not taste great. Ca(OH)2 doesn't add a salty flavor.

Also I have never heard of candied pumpkin and am now extremely curious and invested in your efforts. If you try the calcium chloride, please report back with results!

1
sonofsqueegeeOP•

So I can’t use calcium chloride for crispiness? I have read that people use this for crunch like the pickling lime in the recipe

1