Gifts

So I was wondering, I know everyone had loved gifts, but will they accept other gifts too? Because I know Abigail responds well to quartz but on the wiki it’s not listed as a “loved gift”.

So if I can give them gifts that aren’t loved gifts that they respond well too, what could I give people like Elliott? (Ps. I hate fishing that’s why I’m asking about Elliott lol. And I know eventually I’ll have to suck it up but if you have answers please help me.)