FSR 3 & Frame Generation

Discussion

New to PC gaming in general and decided to go with AMD for CPU and GPU. Felt like I may have made the wrong choice after I started researching FSR vs. DLSS and it seemed unanimous that DLSS was superior and that FSR actually made games worse.

Long story short I got a free key for the new Avatar game that utilizes FSR 3 and Frame Generation when I bought the 7800 x3d CPU and I am blown away by both the performance and resolution. I game at 1440P on a 144hz monitor I am getting 200+ fps with all settings on ultra and high. The game is gorgeous and for these eyes I cannot see any downside to FSR 3. I hope more games start offering this level of performance for this technology.

Posted Dec 9, 2023, 9:12 PM UTC

714
b0gdan82•

FSR is getting better with time. Even DLSS was very bad when it first launched... I didn't play avatar but it seems people like the FSR implementation in that game.

Anyway FSR will have its advantages/disadvantages and the same goes for DLSS. The thing is that DLSS is more mature because it was released two years before FSR. AMD engineers will eventually catch up to DLSS...but probably when that time comes people will find another topic to argue about lol.

12
YouR0ckCancelThat•

I loved the last line! So true...

3
bubblesort33•

You have to see FSR besides DLSS to see the difference. Also look at the Hardware Unboxed review to show the downside of frame generation. Right now the UI gets a bit messed up with it enabled. Seems like it should be fixable, though. Don't know why it launched like that.

FSR2 or 3 doesn't make the image worse, and no reviewer who said that is worth listening to. FSR1 did have that effect on textures some of the time. It would smooth edges but also degrade texture quality occasionally. Might be watching old stuff from like 2020.

Also, Avatar has a better implementation of FSR than most games. FSR breaks up more in motion, and if you test something like Cyberpunk you'll see their denoises for RT with FSR is significantly slower, especially in reflections. If you pan away by and back the image will look horribly grainy for about 1 second, but what really feels like 2 seconds on actual use. DLSS3 is massively better if you're using ray tracing for that reason. Without RT the gap closes a little, but it's generally still regarded as better.

5
Recent-Camera8901OP•

Thanks for that. I'm not nose to the screen looking for imperfections. I do understand that some eyes perceive more subtleties than others. Some people claim they cannot tell a difference between 60 fps and 120+ fps and to me there is a huge difference. As long as immersion doesn't get broken I am happy with whatever processing magic that gets used.

1
LilBramwell7900X/7900XTX•

Avatar is like the first game to get proper FSR 3 support. So pretty much no-one has been able to see if the tech is good. Hopefully it is, because FSR 2 compared to DLSS 3 is an embarrassment.

4
Recent-Camera8901OP•

Avatar isn't my type of game but this gives me hope for the future of this technology. It is implemented very well in this game IMO.

3
rizsamron•

The main difference is that Nvidia is making their techs with only their products in mind so mostly exclusive and requires specific hardware/software designs while AMD tries to create tech that could be leveraged by basically anyone, even Nvidia, something like a "standard" tech i.e. FSR and Freesync. Obviously, AMD's approach is so much more harder and complicated to do hence, the difference in quality between them and competing techs in approximately the same development time. Only time will tell if AMD's techs will improve further to the point that the gap in quality is insignificant, I'm really hoping they will.

In context, this is very similar to the PC and mobile world. Apple creates their techs specifically for their finite number of products while Microsoft (Windows) and Google (Android) are developing them for different companies/people to use with basically unlimited number of configurations. Apple's products are arguably "better" especially their ecosystem because of this much like Nvidia I think.

3

what GPU?

1
Recent-Camera8901OP•

7900 XT

1
Bzk26•

After playing about 3 4 hours of Avatar with FSR and Frame Gen looks good. There might be little details off if you really look for it but if you enjoy the game it does not impact the playability of the game.Frame gen adds about 30 40 fps.

1
Recent-Camera8901OP•

I'm sure it depends on the hardware but on almost every setting maxed out, maxed render distance and detail I am getting 190 - 210 fps at 1440p native setting. Not using FSR I had a mixture of med. and high settings not able to max out render distance and detail and I was getting 60 - 70 fps.

1
Active_Club3487•

AMD is just the best way for gaming.

1
Recent-Camera8901OP•

2 months in and I agree. I know AMD has its issues BUT most people complaining have troubles caused by either their settings or compatibility issues with older hardware including the type and amount of RAM they have. Windows also has a poor track record of breaking things with updates. Absolutely lemons get sold and have to be RMA to get it fixed. I got one of the first PS5's from Sony direct and within 1 month I started having overheating issues. Had to send it back and be with out for 6 weeks but when I got it back it has worked flawlessly since.

1
Active_Club3487•

Every manufacturer has issues, it’s in how you deal with them that counts. I’m 8 months into a conversion from Intel/ Nvidia to AMD. No issues. Small case issue with Hyte they solved it in a week. So, very please with new build.

Ryzen 5 7600, Sapphire Pulse 7900XT

WINDOWS has cause a few issues, but I just reinstall or upgrade Adrenaline, then no problems.

AMD is raster fast, easy and feels good to be on the right side of history…

2