Seeking Help: Identifying and Caring for My First Fish
I recently got my first fish and need help with a few concerns:
- I was sold 2 tetras and 1 fish labeled as a "guppy" at Petco, but after comparing with online images, I suspect it's a red velvet swordtail.
- The fish is about 2 inches long. I'm worried because swordtails reportedly grow 5-6 inches and my tank is only 10 gallons.
- The fish sometimes has a string-like substance (possibly poop) hanging from it for hours.
- Since yesterday, it has developed a white spot on its lips.
- I'm using specific water conditioner and food (pictures attached). Are these suitable for beginners and for this fish type? I read about feeding them a varied diet including frozen dried daphnia.
- I changed the water yesterday (can't remember if he had the lips like that before). Also, I think I messed up here. I changed like 25% of the water... but some people recommend 10 to 15%.
- The current water parameters are: pH 7.2, KH 80 mg/L, GH 150 mg/L, Cl2 0, NO2 0, NO3 0.
I've attached pictures for identification and advice on care. I want to ensure the fish stays healthy.
Thanks in advance.
Posted Dec 17, 2023, 6:51 AM UTC
I'm not experienced with swordtails and GloFish (tetras especially), but you'll need to rehome that guy unfortunately. Those GloFish skirt tetras are schooling fish (6+ minimum) and are gonna need a 20G (long ideally) for most tetras (I think)
I don't think poop looks like that, usually should be brown or green (from veggies, etc) and thick depending on what you're feeding. Green poop is usually from plant matter via peas, algae, cucumbers, etc.
The products you have are okay, nearly any water conditioner on the market is the same more or less, you should get a big bottle so it lasts longer. A lot of people use SeaChem Prime, but I use the big Aqueon Water Conditioner bottle because it's cheaper and works the same.
Now personally, I'm not a huge fan of flakes, they're just messy and don't "feel" great. I prefer live foods or pellets, but that's up to preference as long as you give your fish proper nutrition based on their diet. You can even cultivate your own live food! Varied foods are best if you can, I give my male betta one brand of pellets (picky eater) and my female rescue eats everything. I feed both live mosquito larvae in the summer occasionally as a treat.
I'm not sure on my diseases, but some potential ones are: ich, epistylis, columnaris, or something else. However, I'm willing to believe it may have something to do with their genetics as well. Someone else may have to elaborate on this.
How long have you had them? Is the tank fully cycled? Fish-in cycling or just ghost feeding? A cycled tank makes all the difference for these fish, stress makes them very susceptible to disease and with ammonia/nitrites/high nitrates, it worsens their condition unless healthy. It's great you're willing to learn! I think these types of fish are a little big for your tank, but temporarily it would do since you've only got 3. Nano fish like chili rasboras or a betta would be much better suited :)
(If I'm wrong, could someone please elaborate in detail? I'm willing to learn as well!!)
Thank you for the response.
First of all, bad news: the fish died overnight.
As for the info I forgot to provide:
The tank has 2 weeks. And the fish entered the tank just 1 week ago.
And the stript tests I have do not test for amonia!! I need to hurry and buy one of those because now I am fearing for the other two remaining fish.
Sorry to hear that!
My guess is an ammonia spike. A tank can take up to 6 weeks from scratch to complete the nitrogen cycle. Tap conditioner helps but it still takes weeks for the bacteria to build up enough to counteract the ammonia from the fish.
When you go get an ammonia test (if you have the money def get the API master kit), I would also get some quick start from API. It has the nitrifying bacteria in it that can fast track the cycle. Seachem prime and stability are also good for encouraging this process (labcon is probably fine too, I just don't use it myself).
Id also do a water change asap. Dead fish can release ammonia so overnight shouldn't have produced too much but if there's already a buildup, you gotta get that diluted fast.
Ammonia level was at 1, so maybe that. I will go buy one of those drops to reduce ammonia for now, and get 4 more tetras so they can school and be happier
Definitely that! That's super high. Water change too then add drops.
Also, I would not get more tetras. Id try to re-home them if you can, unless you're going to upgrade tanks.
A school of tetras need a minimum of 20g. If you want schooling fish, you need nano fish (ember tetras, chili or green rasboras, cherry barbs) for a 10g. If you want only 2-3 larger fish, you could look into honey or dwarf gouramis, or even get more sword tails, but you would need to get rid of the tetras either way.
I also suggest not adding any more fish until your ammonia levels read zero multiple days in a row. Your tank is not cycled yet.