Secret Lair cards came crimped :( do people collect these or should I get a replacement?
reddit.com/gallery/18ldpn8Posted Dec 18, 2023, 5:06 PM UTC
Posted Dec 18, 2023, 5:06 PM UTC
They should still be upset that the QC on a premium product is shitty. I’m sure the layoffs at Hasbro will help reign in these problems.
QC is pretty bad. even if you get a good pull nowadays theres a chance its scratched up. makes me want to not really spend anymore money on magic
Fortunately, CEO Chris Cocks is still making $9 million so that should help with QC
It has (along with other issues) stopped me from buying sealed products completely
Ditto, the 'counterfit' product I get is normally the same or better quality at a fraction of the price.
Same, I've gone full proxies but want them to give me a reason to come back. Just voting with my wallet the best I can.
I quit a while ago. Bought a couple secret lairs early on but stopped as soon as it became obvious they were just going to keep cranking them out like every other product. Same for commander precons and sealed product in general. At this point if I need singles I'll go to an LGS and WotC can keep the rest of their crappy FOMO shovelware.
Right, like what if this was going to be a Christmas present? Cool, it'll be replaced, but the replacement won't be in on time lol
The QC of the American arm of a Private Belgian company is going to be affected by layoffs at Hasbro?
Thanks for the advice lads, I'll check with some of those groups first to see if anyone is interested :)
Don't accept the first offer. Most sales are done as an auction in thread.
This is probably a MASSIVE attraction to misprint groups. Would probably auction fairly well
OTOH this seems to be such a common problem with recent secret lairs the uncrimped versions might fetch more on the secondary market.
Seems odd since this is product damage, not misprint. This is mechanical damage done by a crimper in the packaging steps. Anyone could do this to any card they wanted. There’s no way to verify validity and no actual printing process mistake here.
I’m not saying no one would buy them, but I will say they’re fools if they do.
The market for crimped cards is small enough that it is probably not profitable to produce them en masse.
Crimped cards are very commonly bought on misprint groups
Anyone could do this to any card they wanted.
As often as people will insist that faking a crimp is easy, it's not.
There's a private group of researchers among the misprint groups, who try to replicate different kinds of errors to see what is 'safe' to collect and what is 'unsafe' because it can be replicated. We know how crimps happen and we know the exact tools needed to make them but there are always tiny 'tells' that nobody can seem to get exactly right, even under ideal conditions. Still, a lot of people choose to just not bother with crimps anymore because at some point someone will be able to perfectly reproduce them.
"How would you know if a perfect crimp came along?"
That's the million dollar question and it's the reason why we look at more than just the card when deciding whether or not to allow it into a group, which is a statement I'll leave to be intentionally vague.
Like I said- I’m not claiming people don’t buy them. It’s just a dumb thing to pay for, because it’s not a misprint and is easily reproducible.
My understanding is it’s not actually very easily reproducible
False.
People have claimed this before, and bounties have been offered for proof of it. None have successfully claimed it.
I'm not too informed but I've seen a couple posts showing similar defects and it seems that they normally aren't too expensive for this type of defect. Probably wait for a second opinion of someone who knows a bit more but I'd just get replacements by contacting wizards and letting them know what happened.
Nah, these are nice crimps on very played cards. I'd try to check out misprint groups first for sure.
How are these even crimped to begin with? Crimping happens when the seal on a booster is closed, these aren't packaged the same way
They come sealed in a little plastic thing that needs to be crimped closed.
These are crimps on two automatic inclusions and another extremely playable card, a matching set of them no less, I'd be shocked if OP can't make it well worth their time to sell them.
People collect these heavily! "They are worth what someone is willing to pay."
I recommend you check out both MTGRarities: Major Misprints and MTGRarities: Minor Misprints on Facebook!
As some have already said. Do an auction. These are most likely going to fetch a decent premium.
Theyre free real estate. yada yada facebook groups, collectors of missprints etc
I would def ask for a replacement. Mine were flawless.
Sigh, I've been debating getting this secret lair in galaxy foil for my Myra deck (which I'd like to galaxy foil out eventually). Seeing these in photos makes it much harder to say no.
I’m in the same boat the cards are so pretty but the value vs the price is hard to justify but they look so good. It’s hard to pay $50+ for maybe $10 worth of cards but at least they will all be used
People do collect these and you could easily sell them online, yes. However, they don't typically attract an especially high premium as errors are so common in contemporary products.
When I scanned your post, I noticed words or phrases, like "should I get", which usually mean someone wants to buy/sell/trade, or is looking for advice on buying, selling, or trading. I have removed your post because of this.
If you are offering to buy, sell, or trade cards or other Magic-related products, please use the latest weekly buy/sell/tread thread to do so.
If you are looking for advice on buying, selling, or trading, including what to buy or whether to keep or sell particular cards, please use our latest daily questions thread to do so. This is also a good place for "I'm a new/returning player, what things should I get" questions.
IF YOU THINK THIS REMOVAL WAS AN ERROR, DO NOT ATTEMPT TO RE-MAKE THE SAME POST WITH DIFFERENT WORDING. Instead, please message the human moderators of r/magictcg. I am a bot, and I cannot help if you reply to me. As proof that you have read this message in its entirety, please include the answer to the question: What is the name of the game this subreddit is about? as your first line.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Man those are beautiful with the foil
Out of curiosity, how did you get these already? I'm just curious because I was going to pick this lair up. Do they start shopping immediately upon announcement?
This specific drop started shipping on the 6th. Each drop is different.
But if you're in EU shipping starts on the 26th of January :)
For the US region they've updated their shipping to a more on demand format as opposed to waiting months after the run.
Congrats!
As a former yuguoh player I made it a think to have a collection of crimped/ cards damaged through manufacturing or even misprints. These are like gold mines for me! I know the magic community feels a little less about it. But to me they are insanely special!
What is this secret lair? It’s pretty
It’s in the shoot right now. https://secretlair.wizards.com/us/en/product/879332/through-the-wormhole-galaxy-foil-edition
People collect these AND you should get a replacement.
Definitely get a premium on the miscut crimp Facebook groups.
I'd submit a WOTC ticket first and send time stamped photos with your name and product code first.
SELL THEM
Both!
Those are technically damaged cards, so contact WotC and get a replacement. You'll most likely get to keep these ones too, so you can sell them to a collector.
recently had some cards replaced. they make you fedex them back
I had my Genesis arrive bent from the advent calendar. I contacted support about it and then just sent me a replacement without needing the card back.
Weird. I guess because my damaged card was a mox opal.
Possibly, but that would be kinda scummy to base it off of the specific card. Maybe it is the type of damage? If it is a crimp I would expect that to go through no issue, as most people can't do that at home.
Money sets/card u gotta send back. Way back i bought an eternal masters box nd fresh out all the foils were curled. Mtgallison messaged me when i posted here about submitting a claim, they wanted the entire box back to send me a new one….. i opened some decent non factory damaged stuff so i said fuck that. Here i am years later still tryna flatten the foils
I also received a damaged mox opal. Created a ticket with them around the beginning of November and sent out the card. I'm just hoping that I receive the replacement soon. Did you get yours replaced?
I can confirm that they made me mail back my last damaged secret lairs.
Took over 3 months to get them again.
I had a damaged secret lair and they let me keep it and sent me a replacement so maybe it depends how damaged they are?
Honestly probably 100% relies on who you get at support some people are probably 100% by the book whereas others are more laxed.
Just going to confirm as well I’ve had tons of damaged product over the years and they made me send it back every single time.
my first lair was the party hard and the angrath came ultra bent, contacted wotc and got sent a whole new lair without sending mine back. I live in Mexico so maybe shipping was a factor there, but who knows.
There are WotC employees collecting these, I've seen them bidding in the Facebook groups. I wonder what happens to the cards after you mail them back.
Source?
I believe OP mentioned their source: Facebook misprint groups.
Source: I sold some cards in the misprint group a couple of years back and one of them was shipped to a Seattle address, which I thought nothing of at the time until I saw a guy with that name appear in a WotC video explaining a new product. And his Facebook profile name was an alias.
Gets "disposed" of
I received a damaged card in the 30th anniversary countdown kit and they sent me 3 new copies for just a picture, never sent back the damaged one. They probably make you do it if you claim the expensive card was damaged, I just got a Glimpse of Nature replaced
Adding my anecdote to the pile- I’ve had two secret lairs and a commander deck card replaced, never had to send anything back to them.
I got the food chain / first sliver secret lair and they came damaged, they sent a new order and did not make me send them back.
this is the way.
I can confirm that it’s a crapshoot as to whether or not you’ll be able to keep them. I’ve had to get two replacements from bad cards before and in one instance I got to keep, in the other I had to send them back. It’s the holidays, so I’d say the chances are that you’ll be able to keep them.
True, my return was around the holidays, too. I remember they did say I'd have to ship mine back, but I said I ain't paying for gas money to replace a 25-cent card. And they said don't worry about returning the old one they will just replace.
Opened this post to say this, kudos to the good work sire.
So if I were to (hypothetically) pull a high value card, such as the recent mana crypts or a serialized card that was damaged due to a packaging error, they would replace it? And would it just be them sending with equivalent value? Or a copy? Especially curious how that would work with serialized cards.
I didn't know they'd replace them in the first place
Well, it is important to note that WotC (claims) not to acknowledge the secondary market, so they shouldn't care about the value of the card. When it comes to how the replacement works, they replace the card for what it should be. If you javelin a damaged Mana Crypt, they would send you an undamaged one. As long as the damage was done on their end. For serialized cards, I am unsure since the printing is only done X times.
Piggybacking off top comment, sorry. But can someone tell me how it's possible for these secret lair cards to be crimped at all? As far as I know, crimping occurs when cards are sealed inside a booster pack and I don't recall secret lairs coming in the kind of plastic packaging that would crimp the card (except for the bonus card). Am I just misremembering?
They do come in crimped packaging. It's the clear plastic one that looks like a clear booster wrapper, like you'd get promos in in your prerelease kits.