r/lotr•
matrowl

Who knows what you’ve spoken to the darkness?

Books vs Movies

Posted Dec 21, 2023, 1:16 AM UTC

2012
bi-king-viking•

That’s one of the things I love about the films. They’re able to take Tolkien’s original words and fit them into the cinema narrative. They need the story to go a certain way, or a character to say a certain thing, but rather than making up their own dialogue, they pulled from the Professor’s own words.

I’m of the opinion THAT is why these films feel so true to the books. A huge percentage of the lines are lifted right off the page.

13
matrowlOP•

Agreed. I’m a soft apologist for the Hobbit films, but they suffer greatly from not enough Tolkien. Same with ROP times a hundred.

5
bi-king-viking•

I’m apologist about the Hobbit films too, just because of the difference in pre-production time.

For LotR they had YEARS to prepare and make hundreds of swords and individual unique orc costumes and do so much planning and preparing to make it right.

With the Hobbit, Guillermo del Toro was originally going to direct the Hobbit, but left/was fired three months before they were scheduled to start production. Peter Jackson was brought in last minute and the studio refused to move the release day. So PJ had three months to prepare. So there was no time to get anything right. They just had to make it and move on basically.

It’s a tragedy imo. He didn’t get to do the Hobbit justice.

3
matrowlOP•

As far as short as they fall from LOTR, they’re still better than 70% of the slop churned out by Disney and co.

4
bi-king-viking•

Agreed!

2

I honestly want to learn more about the struggle that PJ had to go through for the filming hobbit. I feel so bad for him the more I’ve learned bc he really does seem like a big nerd and wanted to do the best he could.

3

Oh god it’s so much worse than I thought. Poor Poor Peter Jackson. That poor man. I feel so bad for the production team. Fuck the people that didn’t let them push back the timeline… https://youtu.be/20vA9U7J2qQ?feature=shared

3

Wonderful scene.

2
zeuspaichow79ed•

awe do ee dambaylaa

1
blackdutch1•

Did Grima play a part in the death of the King's son?

1