Random natural gas smell in vents

As of this past Saturday I’ve noticed a slight natural gas smell in one of my air vents. It’s never done this in the past and it’s been doing it off and on since Saturday. I’ve had the gas company out and they couldn’t find anything, and I just had an HVAC tech out here and he said it’s “not possible” for the gas smell to enter the vents and come in to my home. It doesn’t happen every time the heat kicks on but every once in a while it will, usually after the heats ran. I’ve also been outside to the furnace and can smell it coming out of the exhaust on the unit. Am I going crazy or is there a legit reason for concern here? Im not sure who to call next about this.

Posted Dec 26, 2023, 9:23 PM UTC

36
Punkag•

Your furnace may be creating excessive c.o, then drawing some of the exhaust in your fresh air intake. check when its cold and dark out, easy to confirm with a flashlight.

1
hunnerrOP•

What exactly would I be looking for? I’ve had 3 HVAC guys out here and nobody can figure out what’s going on still. It was building up in my return when the unit wasn’t running

1
WhatisSuperheat•

Some homes will get faint natural gas smells on failed ignitions. If your furnace has direct ignition or an intermittent pilot, it's possible.

1
ViolentCrimes•

How old is your furnace?

1
hunnerrOP•

Installed in 2020, not sure the actual age of it but i still have a warranty until 2025 so it can’t be that old

1

Check you condensate trap. If it is dry, the smell could be sewer gas.

1
hunnerrOP•

So just a quick update to this:

I just so happened to check the return after posting this and the mercaptan smell coming from it just about singed my eyebrows off. Gas people came out and red tagged my furnace. I had an HVAC company out this morning and the guy could not pinpoint what’s wrong. He suggested replacing the gas valve. He’s now quoted me over $800 to do that. That’s seems a little insane plus my unit is still under warranty. Am I getting ripped off??

1