Vaush is Wrong about Community Gardens
Not only can community gardens and local farms produce enormous amounts of highly nutritious food per acre, they are necessary for a good future.
I've volunteered for seven different community gardens, market gardens, and local farms over the last ten years or so, and I've seen a wide spectrum of organization and effectiveness. One garden was able to donate eight thousand lbs every year to the local food banks, but then was hampered because the head of the organization didn't want to forcibly remove woodchucks from the surrounding woods (they were very cute I must say). On the other hand, a non-profit farm I volunteered for donated at least three times that with only a handful of dedicated volunteers, three full time workers, and a small tractor.
Intensive agriculture and market gardens are very productive per acre by necessity (otherwise they wouldn't survive), their economic scaling problem is that it takes a lot of labor hours to achieve that. Thus the nonprofits and volunteers. But no one who has ever set foot in a small city garden believes it can provide sufficient calories for anyone. It's insulting to suggest that anyone actually on the ground is claiming that. They're not growing cereal grains. They're growing fruits and vegetables, greens and herbs, gourds and flowers. They're making honey, planting fruit and nut trees, making compost.
Anyone who has ever eaten produce from a well-run garden knows it's tastier than whatever you can get at Walmart. But it's also far, far more nutritious. Vitamins, minerals, micro-nutrients, beneficial bacteria, etc. are the literal basis of our metabolism, so to call freshly picked vegetables, fruits, herbs, and spices 'medicine' in our factory farm culture isn't actually new age bullshit, it's the correct and best possible perspective to have about food. Food is the foundation of health.
In food deserts, where poor and homeless people are forced to eat ultra-processed high-fructose shit-cans and fake bread, getting them a supplement of fresh, flavorful produce should be a high priority, right along with the core needs of shelter, clothing, clean water, etc. Every good doctor, psychologist, and social worker will agree. Even better if they can get that produce in a vibrant community space that can give them a little wholesome physical work to do. Even better if that space is part of a network of other gardens, farms, community kitchens and pantries, local restaurants, etc.
People who take part in these projects are happier and healthier. They cook for themselves and others. They learn about local ecology and how to support it. They make connections and friendships. They make community. Vaush's bad take here makes me question his wider view of activism and social progress. His bias against people who like witchy stuff and his apparently uncontrollable cringe reaction to people talking about alternative medicine is just going to help tear down the tiny tide-battered islands of mutual aid that people are desperately trying to build in an age of despair.
We need nature in the cities, we need food to be grown closer to where we live, we need everyone to have the chance to dig in the dirt and help feed their communities. We'll always have large-scale agriculture, but we need medium and small-scale agriculture too. The real problem of community gardens is that there aren't enough of them.
Posted Jan 1, 2024, 7:58 AM UTC