Damage estimate between 3rd party and insurance affiliates are wildly different.

Auto

I got a damage estimate locally with an out of system body shop but due to rental car circumstances, I decided to go with a place in a larger town that so I didn’t have to coordinate rides.

The estimate I received from the local guy whom I have a great relationship with is approximately 8 grand.

The affiliated shop’s estimate was so much that they went with total loss with a settlement totaling ~13k.

I have not seen a damage estimate with the affiliated shop, despite asking for it. All I’ve received is a vague “the estimator said it was more than the value of the car,” which seems totally ridiculous and is wildly different from the local shop.

As always, speaking to a live human is proving incredibly difficult. I like my car quite a bit, and really want to drag my heels on this one. What avenues can I pursue to get anything positive happening here?

Posted Jan 11, 2024, 5:13 PM UTC

13

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 3 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.