Triple boot Hackintosh?

http://lifehacker.com/5698205/how-to-triple-boot-your-hackintosh-with-windows-and-linux I found this article and was wondering what r/hackintosh thought. I am thinking about doing my first build. I run a Linux laptop and my wife has a MacBook Pro. I am also thinking about getting into pc gaming. I want to build a Hackintosh with Windows and Linux installed. This way my wife can still use OSX and I can use Linux. We can both use Windows if the need arises, gaming and the like. With a beefier desktop for multimedia/work needs, we could both get slimmer cheaper laptops for travel and work. Any advice? Thanks!

Posted Feb 27, 2013, 1:26 PM UTC

816
bense•

All these lameasses are taking the easy way and using multiple harddrives. That shits weak. I had it all on one harddrive on my lenovo r61e. I set it up like this.

1st partition - osx

2nd partition - windows

3rd partition - linux

and then i used the Paragon NTFS driver in OSX, which allowed me to read/write to NTFS volumes. THEN, I symlinked my Desktop, Documents, Downloads, Pictures, and Videos directories in OSX to my directories in windows. I did the same in linux.

6
rosshettel•

THEN, I symlinked my Desktop, Documents, Downloads, Pictures, and Videos directories

That's pretty hardcore. And sounds like a nightmare. How did all the .DS_store files on Windows not drive you mad?

4
bense•

It's not a nightmare. You don't like executing say, 10 lines of code, or 10 commands to save you from rebooting between different OSes because you can't remember where you saved that file on your desktop?

How about being able to use the same iTunes library on both the windows and osx side, where it even keeps playlists, play counts, etc etc.

It is worth the effort. I have been multiple OS booting for the past 13 years.

3
isaaclaughterOP•

I definitely like this idea. Save some money and feel like a pro. Thanks for the paragon tip. Does OSX work well for you? Any major glitches? If it's not a smooth experience, i dont think my wife will enjoy or see the beauty in the hackintosh.

1
thetony2313•

I installed windows, then Linux, then Mac os x all on the same drive and it worked. Then you can make a fourth partition or a separate disk with all your data on it that all the os's can access. NTFS usually works best

2
isaaclaughterOP•

I think this sounds good. I can use one SSD, and add regular disk drives as needed.

2
[deleted]•

There is no reason to use a separate drive for each OS. Honestly, this practice seems asinine at best. There is no reason why all of your OS's can't happily co-exist on one drive. People who do this are just taking the easy way out of the "problem".

I hesitate to use problem, because it really isn't a problem at all if you take the extra care and time to do it correctly. My dual boot OSX/Windows build works flawlessly, and both OS's are on a single 128GB SSD. Save the money you absolutely do not need to spend on three freakin' SSDs and put that towards a better video card or something.

Just follow these steps:

  1. Boot UniBeast drive
  2. Open Disk Utility within OSX install
  3. Click on the drive you intend to use for the OS's, make sure that the partition table is GUID, and set up 3 partitions.
  4. Configure the first partition as Mac OS X Extended, name it Macintosh HD.
  5. Set the other two partitions as "Free Space"
  6. Reboot and install Windows first, then install linux.
  7. Install ML, configure Multibeast, and be happy knowing you saved money!
2
isaaclaughterOP•

And you feel like OSX works just as well on your hackintosh?

1
[deleted]•

Absolutely. Audio works, LAN works, everything works fine.

1
ibtokin•

It's possible, but you'll have to follow the tutorial to the T. Linux and Windows don't play along nicely with each other. I have all three installed on my HP Probook, but Linux isn't booting after fixing Grub, which was fixed after breaking Chimera, which was fixed after breaking the W7 Bootloader.... It's still a work in progress. Good luck!

1
[deleted]•

I've never had a problem dual booting Windows and Linux. Did it multiples times on a dell tower, once on a hp laptop, many times on a dell laptop, once on another dell tower, once on yet another dell tower, and once on a gateway laptop. I think that's it...

NINJEDIT(I don't know what I was thinking, maybe the mac stuff is messing you up, forgot I was subbed here)

2
Cryptan•

I would suggest using a separate drive for Windows.

So you could have OSX and Linux on one drive and Windows on the other.

In my experience Windows likes to take all boot priority, so if you are installing Windows on a drive, just disconnect the other drive just to be safe. The same goes if you are installing OSX and Linux; disconnect the Windows drive. This also prevents you from formatting the wrong partition and simplifies the list of drives a bit.

Good luck!

1
ibtokin•

The guide OP linked to shows you how to work around the bootloader problems you pointed out. It's great for laptops and those with only one hard drive installed.

1
gingaswag6669•

I did not read the guide you posted but personally I used separate SSD's for each OS. Everything boots fine but honestly I think hackintosh's are not worth the effort. Even using 'native' hardware there is always something not working working correctly... Maybe it is me i just do not have the time to fux wit it. So if you have time and patience to mess with the hackintosh side of things your good to go, otherwise stick with a mac laptop and a linux/ windows pc.

1
DamienStrength•

my hackintosh has worked flawless for over 3 years!

2
raygan•

I found it extremely easy to triple boot my Hackintosh, as long as I didn't have any of the OSs sharing a single physical drive. I have OSX and Windows installed on SSDs (inexpensive 64gb ones) and Ubuntu Linux on a small partition on one of my data HDDs. Install was easy for all three and Chimera instantly recognized them all for the boot menu.

I had initially installed Linux Mint, which did not show up on the chimera boot menu. It turned out this was because it did not install the GRUB bootloader by default. Ubuntu does. If you choose a Linux distro that does not install GRUB by default, install it yourself for best results.

1