Newbie looking for advice on live setup and some equipment choice.

[I also posted this in r/LearnMusic and Gearslutz]

So I'm new. Like, very new. I have almost no background in music at all, other than an intense love of it from a listener perspective and a little background in guitar. I also have a background in circuit bending, so I have a good idea of how both analogue and digital synths work.

BUT I WANT TO MAKE SOME MUSIC SO HERE'S MY IDEA.

I want to stick to completely (or almost completely) to a hardware set-up for live performances. I realize that that is difficult, but I'd like live shows to be primarily improvised. The project is going to take influence from noise/industrial (merzbow, boredoms, front 242, skuppy), breakbeat (Altern8, Prodigy), and experimental/chill (808 State, **** Buttons). Other buzzwords could include loops, samples, glitch, ambiance, trap, quiet-loud dynamics.

This is my first endeavor into live sound, so bear with me and feel free to snicker, but this is how I visualize a live set-up:

[circuitbent sk-1]+[Monotron]+[TR-808 clone]+[one other synth] ----> [mixer] ----> [loop pedal] ----> [PA]

The things explicitly mentioned are the pieces I'm already rocking. I have a bunch of other circuitbent things that can and will be used from time to time.

So does this work? Essentially I would have preset patches and rhythm sequences stored, ready to go whenevs. I'd layer things in and out via the mixer and looper.

My second question regards the [one other synth]. In my price range [which does not include true analogue :P] I have narrowed it down to the Roland Jx 305, the Roland Gaia, Roland SH-32, or the trustworthy micoKORG. Perhaps even the Realistic Concertmate MG-1? What are general experiences like? After listening to sound reviews, I still can't decide. Are any of these better than the others for the sound I'm trying to achieve?

I'm sorry for the lengthy post, and thank you for reading!

Posted Mar 1, 2013, 10:58 PM UTC

211
Awkwardlittleboy2112That's no Moog, it's a Bass Station•

For about $100 more than a MicroKorg, you can get an Arturia Minibrute, which IS true analog, and (in my opinion) runs circles around the MicroKorg and Gaia.

8
JhoppaFZ-1/CZ-101/SK-8/SK-1/sammichSID/MKS-7•

Yeah, Minibrute was the first thing that came to mind when OP sounded sad about no analog but said budget included a GAIA. It's also got enough clever input and output ports that integrating it into the setup described should be not only fairly simple, but also quite musical.

4
Awkwardlittleboy2112That's no Moog, it's a Bass Station•

Its sound also fits the genre of music OP is going to play with it, and seems like it would play well with other synths, and be something not incredibly difficult to crack open and play with its guts, which seems like something OP might want to do at some point.

2
MinorSwingOP•

I would definitely have some fun opening up a Minibrute.

2
Awkwardlittleboy2112That's no Moog, it's a Bass Station•

Yeah, maybe even buy another Monotron and wire them together, that'd be pretty gnarly.

1
stylingheadRytm, X0Xio, OP-1, Nanaoloop•

ELEKTRON OCTATRACK?

5
goldncamo•

For what it sounds like you want to make I would recommend none of those things. I would just go for I would just save a little bit more and get an Elektron Octarack/Machinedrum or DSI Tempest.

2
MinorSwingOP•

Both of these things are out of my price range, and I'd rather not blow so much on my first set up. That being said, I have wet dreams about the Tempest. :P

1
rodentdpOT/MNM/MDUW/JU-1/XD-5/K4R•

As a Machinedrum owner, I've gotta say that after you buy some of their gear, you'll wonder how you ever lived without it, especially if you want to get noisy and experimental.

3
MinorSwingOP•

I have given serious thought to the Minibrute, but is the analogue sound worth sacrificing all of the sonic possibilities of a modeling synth? I will not argue that the Minibrute's sound is better; it's a great instrument. The vocoding possibilities of the mircoKORG are what draw me in that direction.

1
coachFoxSCI Sixtrack/Juno 106/Ensoniq SQ80/Novation Ultranova•

When I had a micro korg when they first came out I found the vocoder pretty crappy and basically unusable. I'm not sure I've heard many other people make that complaint so maybe it's just me, but I think you would be better off with a talk box effect pedal after a minibrute than trying to get good sounds out of the microkorgs vocoder.

1