Help me pick between these three pairs of shoes

I am looking to expand my shoe collection. As of right now I have vans rata vulcs and sperry topsiders. My options are:

jack purcells

fred perrys

chambray vans

Which ones do you think would be most versatile? The best looking? I will probably buy two pairs. Thanks in advance!

Posted Mar 8, 2013, 6:21 AM UTC

16
hellarad•

Jack Purcells > Vans > Fred Perrys

2
timbreines•

i like the perrys more than the vans. But yes, JP's are the best.

1
wip30ut•

i like those Fred Perry's the best. You might want to pick up some suede loafers or derbies instead of 2 additional sneaks to step up your shoe game.

2
[deleted]•

I think the Fred Perrys look classy as hell. If you're gonna get two, you should probably get the Jack Purcells and one of the Fred Perrys or the Vans, because the Vans and the Fred Perrys look pretty similar. Not a big fan of the Jack Purcells, though...

1
jrocbaby•

I like jack purcells. I am not really a fan of the other two, but if i had to pick it would be the vans over the fred perrys. that style of shoe just seems to never really be the perfect choice for an outfit. lots of bland, so-so looks with it. It can work, just more likely that it will be average looking.

if you are going to have 4 pairs of shoes I dont think you need to worry much about getting a versatile shoe. instead get the shoes which will make an outfit or two in your wardrobe look killer. get the shoe that makes the outfit perfect. then next time you buy footwear you can do the same and soon you'll have killer outfits instead of a bunch of bland, so-so, average looks.

1
Jabunga•

Lets be honest here, the Jack Purcells are great if you like boring. I see nothing interesting in them and you can buy same kind of shoes for 20 bucks.

The Vans are great if you dress more ''streety'' like you like to wear skinny jeans and a hoodie.

Fred Perrys are the best overall shoe for me. You can wear those with chinos or jeans.

I would choose Fred Perry > Vans > Jack Purcells

1