Timeless Elves for BO1 Feedback

Decklist

Here is my first draft of the list. So far, I've been having pretty strong results with it. Haven't hit Mythic yet, but I'm 16-3 as of now, with all 3 of my losses being to various control lists. The shell is based off of the Historic Elves lists that were popular in the past, but now with a greater focus on benefiting from the broken cards Timeless has to offer, namely Natural Order. I wasn't really sold on it at first, but having DRS's creature types matter pushed me into giving it a try.

​

Some thoughts so far:

I like the deck a lot more than some other NO lists because it feels extremely reasonable to just hardcast your NO targets. The deck can't cast Atraxa, but casting hoof turn 4 is extremely possible.

Chord of Calling is still incredibly good. I wasn't entirely sure it was worth running as a 4 of, but the instant speed creature tutor + convoke effect means you can hold it up to get value out of creatures in response to removal of a key piece like an archdruid. The deck very consistently presents a turn 4 combo kill with craterhoof in matchups versus non-interactive decks like Titan and can present a kill over the top of an active field of the dead + Titan.

Natural Order is broken and incredibly versatile. The biggest thing that stands out to me relative to the Historic list is how easily you can build momentum again. In Historic, it can be very difficult to recover from sweepers or repeated removal, but 4 mana and any 1 drop dork can become an Atraxa, which stabilizes your board state, refills your hand, and puts a fairly quick clock on the opponent. Atraxa is also incredibly sticky versus a lot of decks and it's not uncommon to see people concede in the face of a turn 3 Atraxa. Having a backup plan to do something broken that doesn't require a mass of creatures is pretty amazing. Theoretically, Natural Order can let the deck present a turn 3 win as well, but it requires a fairly specific hand.

Once Upon A Time was fairly banned. Not much to say other than it makes things way more consistent.

Allosaurus is great, but it's still a 1/1. Having it provides a backup wincon if I struggle to put anything together. Swinging out with a few 5/5s does just kill the opponent and the resistance to counterspells is always welcome.

1 off Fierce Empath seems right. It's fetchable with Chord of Calling and is a body for hoof and Archdruid. I was on more, but I don't know if it's as relevant as it is in Historic for finding a hoof.

Speaking of 1/1s, I don't really feel it as bad as you'd think. On the play, the opponent doesn't get a chance to bowmaster your 1/1 before you can play an Archdruid, and you should generally be mulliganing for a hand that has either a very fast Natural Order to play the Atraxa Midrange game or a dork -> archdruid -> build up board -> craterhoof kill game anyway. It's a bit rough on the draw, but the deck is much better at recovering from early removal than a Historic list would be due to Natural Order/Once Upon A Time.

I have 0 clue what my landbase should look like. 1 off Boseiju feels as free as it does in almost any green list. I don't know how many caverns I should be playing, and I'm not particularly sure my Castle Garenbrig/Forest ratios are fine. I have more fetches than fetchables, but I don't think it ultimately matters that much. I can't imagine it being relevant to have more than 6 Forests in play, and I want 8 fetches for my 4 DRS. Maybe for BO3 I'll go down on landcount, but I want the 20 lands for BO1 shuffler purposes, assuming I understand how it works. Correct me if I'm wrong, here, but I'm pretty sure 20 lands means the shuffler will try and give me a 2 land hand in BO1, which is what I want for maximizing T2 archdruid consistency.

Other than that, I feel reasonably confident on the core of the list. Every 4 of I'm 100% sure I should be playing, and I'm a bit less confident on the exact ratios of everything else. I know I want some combination of them, but BO1 is a bit difficult to do. I'll have a BO3 list eventually, but I got into Arena not too long ago and I don't have the wildcards to go build a sideboard yet.

​

Overall, I don't think it's better than Titan, but it's certainly a deck that is an appropriate speed for the format, plays the requisite density of broken cards to feel at home in Timeless, and feels like something that's worth playing. I've not run into Rakdos Breach or gotten turn 1/2'd by a Storm/Combo list so far, and I feel like that's largely been luck. I don't think there's much to do against those in a BO1 list other than take the L, queue again, and hope you can race them better next time.

I have concerns about its ability to play into sideboard matches in BO3, but I think that's something I'll address when I have the wildcards/experience with the format to begin building a sideboard. It might just remain a primarily BO1 archetype, much like the Historic lists it draws from.

Posted Jan 26, 2024, 7:28 AM UTC · edited

1011

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 11 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.