Should UNWRA be closed down, and its mission, budget, and resources handed over to UNHCR?

UNRWA is no longer fit for purpose, and arguably never have been. UNRWA and its employees by extension are prime examples of “regulatory capture” by their clients, Palestinian refugees. For those who don’t know the history, UNRWA was the first refugee assistance agency formed by the UN, after Israel’s 1948 war and the ceasefires (not peace treaties or surrender) which followed. The Arabs insisted a refugee agency be set up whose goals were to assist refugees but also keep them and their descendants refugees forever in the hopes one day there would be regime change in Israel somehow (e.g., through another war) and thus to keep them on the borders ready to fight another war rather than permanently resettle them.

Suffice it to say this general approach to refugees and just letting them fester for decades in the opportunistic hopes of the victor country’s collapse and their triumphant return somehow didn’t seem like the most practical or humane thing to do with war refugees, so another UN agency was formed, UNHCR, which has dealt with every other refugee crisis since, with the goal of permanently resettling refugees in a safe country, not making them into restive populations, guerrilla warriors, terrorists or suicide bombers.

So with that bit of background, even if UNRWA aid workers were individually just politically neutral professionals, teaching schools, providing food banks and so on, the very existence of this agency to eternally prop up and support Palestinian nationalistic political resistance, terrorism and war is questionable. But most of these professionals, like those in similar NGO aid organizations do empathize with their clients and their victimhood politics and false narratives and become advocates for that destructive and counterproductive activism.

Since Hamas uses civilian facilities for war purposes, UNRWA schools and warehouses are fair game to store and manufacture munitions and gain access to Hamas’ military tunnel system. The IDF has found that every public facility in Gaza, school, hospital or mosque has at least one connecting shaft and entrance to the tunnel system. The textbooks and curriculum used in UNRWA schools is prepared by the PA and Hamas and preaches jihadist violence, xenophobia and Jew hatred in math and Arabic textbooks and workbooks. It fails UNESCO standards for diversity and peace and have been called out by watchdog agencies like IMPACT-SE.

So, in short, in a rebuilt Gaza and PA territories, UNRWA gotta go and have its educational and aid functions transitioned to a less structurally biased, more secure international relief agency or multilateral group.

(my personal thanks to u/jackl24000 whose comment I copied to extend constructive discussion here.)

Posted Jan 27, 2024, 11:34 PM UTC

73119

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 119 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.