Deriving the perceiving functions from first principals. What are your thoughts?
So I came to semi-relization a while back about why there has to be 4, and only 4, perceiving functions, and why they have to interact the way they do.
I'm keeping this at the bare basics because I want to get all your first impressions before I add my supporting arguments/evidence.
What we perceive leads to memory, and memory is how we are able to gauge the passage of time.
so we have:
Future ______ Ni
Present __ Ne __ Se
Past ________ Si
The past has happened. It has to be a database of states and facts. There can only be one function for it: Si
The future has yet to happen. There is no sensory data available, so there can only be: Ni
The past and future have to be introverted functions because we are either recalling from memory data or recalling a framework we have developed.
The functions that interface with the present thus obviously must be extroverted. We are collecting data from the outside.
There are two way to interact with the present, either through our senses as data points (Se) or viewing the present as a global system (Ne)
Those with Ne must have Si (and vice versa) because we need to know what happened in the past to understand present interactions.
Those with Ni must have Se (and vice versa) because we have to input the present data (Se) into the framework (Ni) to get a result.
So axiomatically, if a personality system were to include something along the lines of how we perceive the world, there must be these 4 vertices, and no more. Of course, this is ignoring all the interactions and whatnot.
And that's where I'll leave. Looking forward to all your thoughts. I'll be back later!
Posted Mar 27, 2013, 12:31 AM UTC · edited
One thing that should be mentioned is that everyone has all 8 functions. MBTI captures our preferences on how we tend to interact with the world, but we still use all the functions. For example, someone with the Ni/Se axis would have a preference for creating new experiences in the present (Se) or thinking about future ones (Ni), but that isn't to say they never remember past experiences (Si).
Of course, totally agree. The best way to visualize the perceiving functions on a grid in the diamond I formed above with them that represents their relative preferences, and then showing how certain types tend to accumulate at certain regions.
It's all about the relative strength of them all, and that's where it all gets interesting. Gotta love complexity. (Ne Ti for the win)