r/mbti•
MagicNine

Deriving the perceiving functions from first principals. What are your thoughts?

So I came to semi-relization a while back about why there has to be 4, and only 4, perceiving functions, and why they have to interact the way they do.

I'm keeping this at the bare basics because I want to get all your first impressions before I add my supporting arguments/evidence.

What we perceive leads to memory, and memory is how we are able to gauge the passage of time.

so we have:

Future ______ Ni

Present __ Ne __ Se

Past ________ Si

The past has happened. It has to be a database of states and facts. There can only be one function for it: Si

The future has yet to happen. There is no sensory data available, so there can only be: Ni

The past and future have to be introverted functions because we are either recalling from memory data or recalling a framework we have developed.

The functions that interface with the present thus obviously must be extroverted. We are collecting data from the outside.

There are two way to interact with the present, either through our senses as data points (Se) or viewing the present as a global system (Ne)

Those with Ne must have Si (and vice versa) because we need to know what happened in the past to understand present interactions.

Those with Ni must have Se (and vice versa) because we have to input the present data (Se) into the framework (Ni) to get a result.

So axiomatically, if a personality system were to include something along the lines of how we perceive the world, there must be these 4 vertices, and no more. Of course, this is ignoring all the interactions and whatnot.

And that's where I'll leave. Looking forward to all your thoughts. I'll be back later!

Posted Mar 27, 2013, 12:31 AM UTC · edited

1011
Stalia•

One thing that should be mentioned is that everyone has all 8 functions. MBTI captures our preferences on how we tend to interact with the world, but we still use all the functions. For example, someone with the Ni/Se axis would have a preference for creating new experiences in the present (Se) or thinking about future ones (Ni), but that isn't to say they never remember past experiences (Si).

6
MagicNineOP•

Of course, totally agree. The best way to visualize the perceiving functions on a grid in the diamond I formed above with them that represents their relative preferences, and then showing how certain types tend to accumulate at certain regions.

It's all about the relative strength of them all, and that's where it all gets interesting. Gotta love complexity. (Ne Ti for the win)

1
Sektor7g[INTJ]•

This is very close to how I teach the perceiving functions to people, which I've been doing professionally for several years now. One distinction- The Ne time focus isn't strictly limited to the present. They actually tend to see time as a metric instead of a continuum, meaning that they bounce around a lot. Ni's see the future by simulating the evolution of present conditions, and watching how they play out. Ne's jump straight to a idea of how things could be, and see what the outlook is from that place.

3
MagicNineOP•

As an ENTP, I know exactly what you mean. Ne is really hard to explain to people sometimes... especially S types. I completely agree with you overall.

And as someone considering going into coaching too, I'm really happy that this is similar to how a professional does it. :D I've been researching non stop for basically a year and a half now, and really coming up with my own theories on type to type interactions. I also have an INFP who has recently become an research partner of sorts. He's great with the emotional aspects we're now incorporating into our framework.

I'd also love to know how to break into the coaching profession. This has become a passion of mine. Thanks!

1
Sektor7g[INTJ]•

Pm me, and we can skype sometime.

1
trex88[INFP]•

makes sense to me

1
MagicNineOP•

Go team ENTP! :D

2
Craig_Craig_Craig•

If Si is used when deliberately recalling past memories, how do I intuit them? My mind instinctively recalls memories - what function would that be, if not Ni? Furthermore, if Ni is not able to recall past memories, then I don't have a function to employ my memory at all in my primary 4. Considering how much I use my memory, this doesn't make sense.

I also see no mention of the introversion or extroversion of functions in your theory. I understand that 'i' functions work based on memories and thoughts, and 'e' functions work based on senses.

1
trex88[INFP]•

there is active and passive use of functions you use all functions passively at most times of the day, but functions that you have somewhat developed you can use actively. ni is seeing a way you need to think and then becoming that. while si is comparing a current event to a storehouse of similar events to see what is consistent. both of them end in the future but the way they do it is different.

1
MagicNineOP•

Si recalls past memories. Intuition is not instinctual recall of facts. Intuition is perceiving the world more abstractly. Sensing is doing so more concretely.

And the 'e' and 'i' represents the direction of the cognitive functions. The past and future are introverted because you're either internally visualizing the future or internally recalling the past, respectively, to then act on. The action, or judging function, thus must be extroverted (Fe and Te). Someone with a dominant or auxiliary introverted perceiving function must have an extroverted judging function: i.e. J types. They are action oriented, rather than P types which are reactive.

No criticism, but I your understanding of what Ni seems to be off. Personally, it took me a long time to truly understand all of the cognitive functions, especially Ni, in terms of how they behave and what the feels like to use for someone who has them as their dom/aux.

May I ask, what is your type? I always like to understand where someone else is coming from.

1
Craig_Craig_Craig•

I'm an INTJ - Ni is my dominant function. I'm very familiar with it, and I'm trying to describe it as precisely as I can. It's a very powerful instinct that often gives me the answer to math problems with no conscious thought, or urges that a certain wire could the fault in an electrical system. It keeps me awake at night with visions of things that could have or will happen.

I say that Ni instinctively recalls facts because, as trex said, functions can be used passively without your conscious mind noticing. Ni will put relevant facts and ideas into your subconscious for Te to process, and then it will take the ideas, memories, and Te's predictions based off of them and put them into your conscious thoughts. It's all wrapped up and presents itself as Ni, but other functions contribute.

1