Can we talk about jagex hiding offence upgrades behind defence requirements
A pure in maxed gear and 99 strength hits 42 with a dragon scimitar (includes infernal and Ultor which are extremely hard to get on 1 def). What strength lvl does a main need to hit 42 with a d scim and maxed gear? Just 76!
Yet funnily enough people want to deny pures 1 max hit through chivalry even if they have a prayer level to use it.
Jagex there is far too much scope creep for gear with defence requirements that I feel it’s messing with the mechanics of the combat triangle. Attack is meant to give accuracy, strength levels increase your max hit and defence decreases the chance of taking damage.
Let’s take the proposed bladed moon as an example. No requirements but 65 defence. That means a zerker with 45 def could gain the same combat lvls to either go 75 attack or 65 defence. Despite attack being the stat aimed to increase accuracy, suddenly the account with 65 defence has far more slash accuracy with a dragon scim than the zerker with the abyssal tentacle. The DDS with the bladder moon is now insane and far better than an abyssal dagger.
I get what peoples response will be - you choose to limit yourself so deal with the consequences. That is not my complaint - my issue is that gear scope creep is circumventing the mechanics of the combat triangle because bonuses meant for attack or strength are assigned to defence requirements.
It makes sense for defence lvls to provide gear with better bonuses to some extent - the current defenders in the game make perfect enough sense - modest attack and strength bonuses and low but increasing def bonuses as the lvl increases. But the bladed moon is completely nonsensical. It’s not named a defender so why not reinvent the wheel a bit? Instead of 65 defence why not 140 attack AB’s strength combined or something? Remove the mith kite shield defence bonus and keep the attack bonus. Mid game players with lower defence levels should have the same chance to take on tougher bosses with higher defence levels and something like the bladed moon could be a good starting point - it actually makes more sense from how the combat triangle and stats are supposed to work.
Posted Mar 3, 2024, 6:51 PM UTC