Question about Saracen Street

Hi all,

I have been tasked with finding accommodations for 3 nights lodging for 5 adults this summer while visiting family, but also trying to keep costs somewhat reasonable. This rules out every hotel that still has availability, as $400-$1000 per night per room is out of the question.

I am having one heck of a time deciding what to do, because (no offense) every single place I try to gauge the status of the neighborhood/area by performing reddit searches and without fail every single one of them results in a response (or multiple responses) stating that the poster would be terrified to be there, it's a shithole, you can smell the sewage plant, you'll get stabbed, etc etc etc. Literally every neighborhood had one or more "Oh don't go there" posts.

I understand that there are people overreacting in every city about this neighborhood or that, but it seems like (if I am using reddit as an example) the entire city is bad.

To be fair, many of the original posts were looking for advice on moving to an area, so the results are going to not exactly line up with what I am trying to accomplish here.

I know some of the history from years ago, and I see plenty of people say that things are vastly improved from how things were in the 70s-the end f the 00s, but it is challenging to find a place, to say the least.

I apologize for the lengthy preface so I will get straight to the point of the post:

Would spending three nights on the far south end of Saracen Street (right near St Teresa of Lisieux Catholic Church) result in our untimely demises?

I looked at the SIMD and while the block is red, it is literally blue a block further south toward the city center. I don't necessarily understand what it all means but people sure like to mention red=awful a lot.

I did a google street view "drive" and honestly it looks like it is fine, but I thought I'd ask here.

We do not plan on late night roaming side streets (or main for that matter), etc, but would like to do without a car until we leave Monday morning to head to the Highlands. There is a bus stop right out front.

The place I am looking at is also rated 9.6 out of 10 by nearly 100 reviewers and a search of all reviews for "safe" resulted in two or three posts saying they felt quite safe even walking all the way to city center. There were no results for "unsafe" "crime" etc.

For some context, I have lived my 52 years in the metro Chicago area, including the first 25 in a blue collar "rough" suburb that looks nowhere near as nice as what I saw on street view.

I've also been the last person on Bourbon Street in New Orleans at 3:30am and I like to think that if I got out of that unscathed that perhaps I'm overthinking all of this.

Thanks in advance for any help and advice!

Posted Mar 11, 2024, 7:01 PM UTC

762

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 62 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.