r/homelab•
CRefice

Mini PC storage: DAS or NAS?

Help

I'm planning on getting a Mini PC as a minimal "homelab" to be able to play around with virtualization/proxmox and run a few media servers, as well as setup some proper redundant storage for my photo library (which I would backup to a remote location automatically) and a growing collection of 4k HDR movies that I would like to stream with Jellyfin to my TV over LAN (only 1 stream at a time).

I've been stuck on planning the storage setup, however. I've seen arguments both in favor and against getting a separate NAS for storage and setup an NFS share with the Mini PC, as opposed to getting a DAS enclosure to attach to the Mini PC via USB.

Pros:

  • Dedicated server for storage, won't lose data by playing around with containers.
  • Possibility to play with TrueNAS Scale and experiment with ZFS (I've heard running it over proxmox and/or with a USB DAS can be problematic). (Yes I know it kinda runs counter to the point above lol)
  • (Maybe?) Better performance due to integrated hardware/software.
  • (Maybe?) More reliable than a USB connection. I've been maintaining a Mini PC + DAS with servers running on bare metal Ubuntu at my parents' place and I have seen some issues with the USB storage not being recognized after a power outage. Though it may just be that specific enclosure that is the problem.

Cons:

  • One more piece of hardware to maintain
  • Takes up more space compared to a DAS
  • More expensive
  • Higher power usage

What would you recommend based on your experience and my requirements?

Posted Mar 12, 2024, 10:38 PM UTC

25

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 5 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.