The origins of the Last Supper

Academic

As JWs go about celebrating the memorial this year, there is often a lot of discussion on this sub about their weird ritual of passing the memorial emblems around but not partaking of them. Many newly awakened exjws who are still in the process of deconstructing their faith often wonder whether or not they should do something to “celebrate” the memorial and partake of the emblems in some way.

This past year, I read an excellent book, Jesus and Paul by New Testament scholar James Tabor, which makes a very compelling argument for Paul being the most influential human in history. Among other topics, it discusses how the ritual of the Eucharist and how the Christian story of The Last Supper originated. Tabor explains why scholars believe that the stories about Jesus instituting the Eucharist are not based on historical accounts, but rather originate with something Paul claims to have seen in a vision.

Tabor really goes into details in its book, but I’ll just provide the bullet points.

• ⁠Pauls first letter to the Corinthians is our earliest account of the last supper. (I always wondered why JWs read from 1 Corinthians when discussing the emblems at the memorial instead of one of the gospels). • ⁠Paul is very explicit that HE is the source for this story and that he did not learn about it from any other human. • ⁠The author of Mark copies Paul’s account from 1 Corinthians. We know this because it’s copied almost word for word in the original Greek. • ⁠The authors of Matthew and Luke then copy Mark. (The author of Luke also has access to another tradition which differs from the one in Mark). • ⁠The author of John seems to suspect the story is made up, as he doesn’t include it in his gospel at all. • ⁠John also has Jesus die ON the day of the Passover, not the day after the Passover, so this is another reason he likely doesn’t include it. (For this author, Jesus has to die on the Passover because he, symbolically, has become the Passover lamb). • ⁠The earliest Christian source we have that is not influenced by Paul that discusses the Eucharist comes from the Didache (if you aren’t familiar with it, think of it like a first century instruction for elders on how the Christian church should function and how to deal with various issues of morality) and doesn’t include any of the ritualistic words equating the bread and wine with Jesus body and blood:

You shall give thanks as folows: First, with respect ot the cup: "We give you thanks, our Father, for the holy vine of David, your child, which you made known ot us through Jesus your child. To you be the glory forever." And with respect to the fragments of bread: “We give you thanks our Father, for the life and knowledge that you made known ot us through Jesus your child to you be the glory forever." (Didache 9:2-3)

In summarizing the chapter discussing this topic, Tabor concludes:

Jesus lived as an observant Jew, keeping the Torah or Law of Moses and teaching others to do the same. Jews were strictly forbidden to consume blood or even ot eat meat from which blood had not been properly drained and removed (Leviticus 7:26-27). The Jewish followers of Jesus, led by Jesus' brother James,were quite stringent on this point, insisting that it applied equaly 'his To non-Jews as wel as Jews, based on the prohibition to Noah and al his descendants after the Flood. They forbade non-Jewish followers of Jesus to eat meat that had been killed by strangling, or to consume any blood (Acts 15:19-20). Paul was admitedly lax on these restrictions and tells his followers they can eat any kind of meat sold in the marketplace, presumably even animals killed by strangulation, so long as no one present happens ot notice and object on the basis of biblical teachings (1 Corinthians 10:25-29). Given this background I think we can conclude that it is inconceivable that Jesus would have had his followers drink a cup of wine as a representation of his blood, even symbolically, or break bread to represent his flesh, sacrificed for their sins.

TL;DR - Jesus had a last meal with his disciples, but probably did not institute the Eucharist.

So my advice would be, if you don’t feel comfortable drinking the wine and eating the bread, don’t stress about it too much. You have plenty of time to figure out your new beliefs.

Note: if anyone is not familiar with Tabor, here’s a recent post discussing his credentials on r/AcademicBiblical. I’d recommend anyone interested in learning more about the Bible subscribe to that sub. You’ll learn so much.

Posted Mar 24, 2024, 1:31 PM UTC

4227

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 27 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.