Gamers of r/gaming, looking for some suggestions on which games to purchase from Plantation Network store.

I was thinking about getting I am Alive or Journey for 15. And its a toss up between Payday, Dead rising 2 or Mafia 2. I like having a multiplayer online mode with games but I'm really just looking for something I'm going to enjoy putting some hours into. I also like racing games and rpgs. Any suggestions would be appreciated.