How would you feel about Sylux taking on the role of Reoccurring Rival from Ridley?

Discussion

So Ridley has been in almost every single Metroid game so far, even appearing twice in Metroid Prime 3 in two different boss battles and added appearances in the epilogues for the remakes of the first two games. It's safe to say that the guy shows up a hell of a lot and some would argue a bit too much. As someone that is a huge fan of Ridley, I'd have to honestly agree. I love to see him show up and all but you can have too much of a good thing. It's why I'm not too thrilled about seeing Ganondorf return all the time, more than Ridley because he always takes the role of central villain. Even when the game already had one, like with Onox, Veran, Zant and arguably Ghirahim.

Sylux is an interesting character, mainly because besides being one of the few reoccurring characters in Metroid he has yet to actually do anything major since his first appearance. In his first appearance he was a frequent presence in the game as one of the other bounty hunters you had to fight. He was also playable in the multiplayer mode, which certainly gave him a leg up in attention. Since then however it's just been brief cameo appearances with the tease of "something is going to happen, just wait for it." It's because of those appearances that people tend to discuss him to this day over the other hunters, even when there's next to nothing we know about him.

Ridley has died and come back many times, either through cloning or cybernetic enhancements. There's only so much you can do there before people want something fresh. Sylux I feel could fill that role. He's a humanoid enemy, so any fights with him could be more on par with Samus. That's something we haven't really seen since Dark Samus who is now pretty much wiped out and arguably the SA-X (though that had you as the underdog rather than equals). He has ties somehow to the Federation due to his tech, which could be elaborated on to potentially tie him to Samus on that front. In fact because he uses stolen tech there's the potential to expand it beyond what he uses in Hunters. That could be part of his appeal, where any fight we have with him will be using something experimental and unseen.

I feel that we should give Ridley a break for a few games, no more appearances for a while. Maybe a mention in scan logs here and there but that's it for now. In his stead we would have Sylux taking over as a secondary villain, not the main one but significant enough in some form to show up. This would also bring about the opportunity to flesh him out as a character, though I would like them to keep some mystery to him. We don't necessarily need his origins explained to us much like how Ridley never did.

Any thoughts on this? I know a lot of people naturally want Sylux to return anyway but what about in this capacity?

Posted May 15, 2024, 7:19 PM UTC

1949

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 49 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.