Opinions wanted on our top 3 girl names

I am so torn! My husband LOVES the name Evelyn (nn Evie, Eve, Ev - we love nicknames ha) and it was my suggestion initially so it’s been our #1 the whole pregnancy, but I know it’s super popular. Our other favorites are Zoey and Clara (family name). Last name starts with S.

I have different middle name preferences for each - Joan/Rose/Elizabeth/Michele are family names. Here’s some examples:

Evelyn Rose Evelyn Claire Clara Rose Clara Rae Clara Joan/June/Jane - nn CJ? Clara Elizabeth Clara Michele Zoey Violet (does this give give trying too hard vibes? lol) Zoey Elizabeth Zoey Michele

Give me all your opinions on Zoey, Evelyn, and Clara !!