The Motoman Engine Break in method. Fact or Fiction?

So, this came up in r/askscience and there doesn't seem to be any ASE certified mechanics over there to answer it. I'm crossposting it here because I think it will be fun to see the ensuing debate, and I want to see opinions from people who aren't a shadetree mechanic like myself.

So I've only ever heard of breaking your engine in as according to the owners manual. Varying RPMs and loads, while avoiding running the engine really hard.

Enter this guy, who says following the manual will lead to blow by and lost power due to the rings not seating correctly. (among other things)

http://www.mototuneusa.com/break_in_secrets.htm

So how about it MechanicAdvice ? Does this guy have a point with your average street vehicle? Or are his theories as sound as putting magnets on your fuel lines?

Whats the right way to break in a new engine? A new car?

Posted Apr 30, 2013, 7:36 PM UTC

1319
Aavagadrro•

Since the advent of roller cams and other rollerized parts that dont have a wear surface similar to the flat tappet cams that required specialized break in procedures, the chances of an engine having issues once its built are lessened considerably. The varied RPM and not allowing it to idle for prolonged periods was more to get the cam and lifters to wear in with enough lubrication. Once that is done, usually within an hour or so, its a good idea to drive it normally.

I usually put between 200 and 500 street miles on one of my drag engines just to make sure everything is working right. Even then the engine isnt broken in entirely, the clearances are still pretty tight throughout, and they always pick up as they wear in.

The biggest change in engines was a 455 Pontiac I built in '97, the first run off the trailer was a 12.80@105, after two months of street driving and four more trips to the track it was running 11.90s real consistent, so we slowed it to 12.10s and picked up better consistency. The best it ever did was 11.71@115, which is a relatively big change from what it started. That engine lasted 7 years of being abused, street miles, long distance trips, racing and scaring motorcycles, then I built a bigger badder one.

It depends on what engine it is, how tight the clearances are, and what the intended use happens to be. I have babied them, beaten on them after the first oil change, and driven them normally. As long as everything is working good, and you built it correctly, there shouldnt be an issue.

7
Obsolite_ProcessorOP•

Lovely! Historical reasons for both sides to be right depending on the technology and applications involved.

Any other examples you know of car break in periods changing with technology? I always love discovering the origins of mechanical superstitions, and how technology has changed to make the problems a thing of the past.

3
Aavagadrro•

Lots of superstitions around cars, and plenty of bogus info out there about all sorts of things car related. My personal pet peeve with cars and misinformation is how so many people will claim ethanol is horrible for cars, how either old cars or new cars cant run it. The Fords built before the Volstead Act were dual fuel, you advanced the timing and turned a knob on the dash to get the air fuel mix right to run on ethanol. You retarded the timing and turned the knob to run gas. Prohibition was more about Rockefeller selling his left overs from kerosene production as fuel than it was about getting people to stop drinking.

The reality of it is gasoline is bad for cars, ethanol is good for them, well if you want your engine and fuel system to last a long time. If you want it to wear out, run hot, make less power, and have carbon building up everywhere in it, then gasoline is great.

It is really easy to find people who have zero first hand experience, assume the problem is the ethanol yet have done zero actual testing to see what the real problem was, and are very vocal about how bad it is. I make fuel on a micro scale, less than 5,000 gallons per year, and run my cars on it. 1970 GTO was the first, all it needed was a carb swap and it was alcohol ready. Next up was a 98 Formula and a 92 F150. I splash mix E85 in a 98 Gran Prix as well. I convert everything and understand how it all works, so I know first hand ethanol doesnt hurt anything in the fuel system or engine.

The ethanol thing is even more hotly contested than tire pressures. Ask about tire pressures, go by the placard or the sidewall and see what you get. My take on pressures is keep it under the maximum but run as much as is a comfortable ride for you. Most of the OEM suggestions is based on NVH concerns, they care less about mileage, tire life, and handling than they do about how smooth it rides.

Ask about ethanol and tire pressures, and see what you get.

2
NickStihl•

This is a project that I've thought about performing on my 70 Monte Carlo.

Would you be able to link any info on the Ethanol subject to us?

1
Aavagadrro•

Lots of info here, but some of it is older, particularly about converting your car to run ethanol. Carburetor modifications can be found at a couple sites. E85forum and E85Performance. I modify QuadraJet carbs to run E85 and HE100, they work quite well too. Holley is easier because they are a simpler carb with fewer possible adjustments. So far there is only one other guy converting Qjets to ethanol, unless Cliff Ruggles has decided to give it a try. Cliff is the ultimate Qjet guru, and I have shared all my info with him, but I dont think he has done any conversions yet.

EFI is really simple, sometimes you need larger injectors because of duty cycle and other times you dont. A couple tuning changes in the ECM and you are good, that is about all it takes. You can also get a piggy back system that plugs in between your injectors and harness, that keeps them open a bit longer and as long as you dont have a duty cycle issue they work great.

All it takes to convert your Monte is a carb swap. My 70 GTO is running the original fuel tank and lines, it has only been upgraded with an electric fuel pump and a carb swap. The fuel pump was needed because the 455 would empty the float bowls on a Holley in 2nd gear with the stock pump on gasoline. I have never put a stock pump back on it.

1
nerdcorerising•

You're not going to get a straight answer anywhere. There is more superstition, hearsay, and general opinion holding regarding engine break in than just about anything else about a car.

You'll hear that you should run it hard, soft, at different speeds, at the same speed, change the oil after 100 miles, don't change it until the scheduled interval, etc, etc.

And the truth is that some engines are already broken in by the factory. There is a big difference between the first run of an engine that has just been assembled and a car you're driving for the first 1000 miles.

My advice is to follow the manual unless you have really convincing reasons not to.

6
HoppyIPA•

Well, I was reading this questions from the perspective of someone building an entirely new engine, with no manual to follow. The Subaru service manual probably doesn't apply to my new motor with forged internals and big cams and turbo.

My biggest issue is that after the initial warm up period, several places recommend running the engine with a least a little boost (10-12psi) while others say to stay off boost for at least 500 miles. The other guys say the boost helps seat the pistons rings.

I understand your point, but in the end people building expensive motors want to make sure it is broken in the correct way. After re-reading your comment, I guess I agree with you. Although for me, my aftermarket internals are a "convincing reason" to seek out the most optimal break-in strategy.

1
eog_prodSupreme Mechanic Burrito•

OP: this is right on the money. You don't have to be ASE certified to understand physics. ASE certified means you have been schooled in their way of doing things and have passed an examination.

If you think about it, a lot of engines are already broken in this way. When a mower or weedeater is purchased by the consumer, they don't limit the loads on the engine until it is broken in. You get in the grass and get the job done.

3
tonytaylor85•

Hydraulic/flat tappet cams required this.

http://www.cranecams.com/uploads/breakin/548e.pdf

Modern roller valvetrains have eliminated this requirement.

3
gonzoforpresident•

When I was at MMI a visiting Honda factory guy told us that the only reason for the break in period on motorcycles was to acclimatize the rider to the bike.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Payador•

Use a Zinc additive or cam break in lube for Flat Tappet cams too, the newer oils have almost eliminated the Zinc. Yes the roller motors do not need the normal old school break in methods. I started avoiding Chrome Moly rings too.

2
NickStihl•

I'm not a metalurgist so I have ask.

Why avoid chromoly rings?

1
Payador•

I had a set in a 400 sbc and they never truly sealed... granted the 400s had very short rods and create more side loading but it was annoying to have blow by however miniscule it was on a new engine jst my personal exp tho

1
TrustTheTrees•

By driving it. Do you regularly take your car to the track and beat the piss out of it? Do you regularly let your car idle in park and slowly rev it up and down? No. Normal city and freeway driving offer the full array of driving conditions that a new car will see every day for (hopefully) many, many years.

1
redoctoberz•

"Whats the right way to break in a new engine?"

However the owner's manual says to.

1
nolotusnotes•

I absolutely hate the folklore, snake-oil and general misunderstandings surrounding automobiles and their respective subsystems and even individual parts.

TL;DR: How a modern day engine is broken-in is largely equivalent to a voodoo spell the owner does to ensure long engine life. Largely pointless, but somehow important to the new owner.

1
HoppyIPA•

Does this type of break-in make more sense for certain types of engines? For example, a freshly built engine with forged internals and an aftermarket valvetrain. Or does the material that the pistons rings are made out of have more an effect of break-in?

What about with turbos? Little boost? No boost?

I know about the issue with flat-tappet cams, although I though more cars still had these.

1
el_muerte17•

Regardless of whether you take it easy or drive the piss out of it, one thing you should avoid as much as practicable is idling. Excessive idling will glaze the cylinder walls and prevent the rings from seating.

1
[deleted]•

I bought a bike from someone who did that to it, and the motor was spewing metal into the oil within a few hundred miles. Like, lots of it. Rebuilt it and broke it in soft, and it ran like a top with no metal in the oil. 2005 Husqvarna SMR510.

0