Need advice for picking a lighter stick for use with disability

Tech Help

Hi Everyone,

I'm in a little bit of an unusual situation. I have a connective tissue disorder called Ehlers Danlos syndrome, similar to OP in this post and this post, as well as the one that Ultra David mentioned in this video and others. The experience of people with EDS varies widely, but as far as games go I started experiencing pain on pad well before my official diagnosis. For me this was finger fatigue, numbness, burning, and hand cramps.

My first and only fightstick was a Madcatz WWE Brawlstick, which I added Sanwa buttons too. It isn't something that I would feel up to using on days I felt particularly bad, but was still worlds and worlds better than the pain I would experience on a regular PS1-PS4 controller.

Unfortunately, I have grown a good deal weaker over the past few years, and can no longer deal with actually picking the fightstick up to put on my lap. It's too heavy and bulky for me to lift, despite being on the lighter end for a stick IIRC. I spend most of the day in my comfy chair in the lounge, and so simply placing the stick on a desk isn't an option for me at the moment. If there was a smaller form factor stick that was easy for me to move around (maybe 1.2kg or lighter or fairly slim) I would stick with a traditional fightstick. I have looked into lighter sticks, but can't seem to find any mini-sticks with decent reviews.

I have been looking into going leverless as well, but fear that keeping both my left and right hand in those positions for extended periods of time may lead to issues. For reference, I can no longer type on a standard keyboard for any prolonged period of time, and instead make use of an 8-key keyboard like this, which has been a real game changer for me. I can't play games using a traditional keyboard, so I fear that a leverless will cause a similar issue.

Surprisingly, playing slower platform fighters on a gamecube controller isn't too uncomfortable for me. I think this has to do with the use of the analog sticks for movements, and the fast repeated use of the face buttons in very quick succession. Playing traditional fighters on pad though leads to a lot of pain, mostly due to the d-pad and rapid pressing of the face buttons, I think.

I've been looking at the Fighting Commander Octa, but wasn't sure given the mixed reviews I've seen. Also, the right side is still a traditional pad, although I have seen NihongoGamer suggest holding it like a fight stick on the right side I am so sorry that this post has been so all over the place. I would like to make a decision very soon, as I live in South Africa and have a cousin coming over from the US at the beginning of next month who I could get the controller/stick/leverless shipped to.

I have made a tl;dr below.

  • I have a connective tissue disorder called Ehlers Danlos syndrome
  • PC is the main platform for me atm
  • Condition makes using a pad for traditional fighting games difficult
  • I have a Madcatz PS3 WWE Brawlstick, but it's become too heavy for me to move around
  • I cannot type on a regular keyboard, and fear that using a leverless might bring up similar issues
  • Outside the US, but could get a relative to bring an order with them if i act quick enough
  • I can use a pad for platform fighters without too much discomfort
  • Looking at hori fighting commander, lighter fightsticks like the hori mini, or at leverless but can't make a decision

Posted Jun 19, 2024, 3:09 PM UTC

87

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 7 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.