"Met the missus" for the first time ever last night.

I've had friends in various sorts of poly relationships for a while. But now that I'm single again, I'm actually dipping my toes into poly myself for the first time, dating a man who lives with his SO. They're officially non-monogamous rather than poly, but apparently there's something about he and I that's a bit more than their traditional non-monogamy and making her a little insecure.

So last night, I went over to their place for dinner, with the idea that I'd be less scary as a known (geeky, normal) as opposed to an unknown. It was weird. The conversation was almost all her telling me (or prodding him to tell me) about his family, or trips they've taken, or traditions they have. I found myself wanting to say "Yes, you're a couple, I get it!", but I restrained myself. That seemed ... inappropriate.

I guess I'm telling y'all because I don't have anyone else to tell. I understand what was probably going on, but it felt weird and uncomfortable. I have no desire to be "the other woman" or to feel like one. I was as unintimidating as I could be, even lost horribly at board games. But I also don't want to put myself in a lot of situations where I don't feel welcome -- where I am to be audience rather than a guest.

Any advice for the newb?

Posted May 9, 2013, 11:38 PM UTC

1117
[deleted]•

There's a limited amount that you can do to mitigate her unease from your point, and it sounds like you're playing it right. I think it's important for her to get more comfortable with you through exposure, to make her feel like you're not trying to break her world apart but rather to find a place in it. It might be less uncomfortable if you had some interaction on some neutral ground - maybe invite them both out to a bar or restaurant. Its not critical that you and she become best friends, but rather like in-laws you really need to at bare minimum get in the mindset of being on the same team. Unfortunately half that is on her, so I'm crossing my fingers for you.

As an aside, put this in your back pocket in case you ever find yourself on the other end of things. The silver lining of some rotten experiences my partner has had in the past is that she now goes way above and beyond to make anybody I date feel welcome and part of the team - which naturally makes me try to outdo her when she meets somebody. Makes for a very happy poly relationship when your primary partner is your best wingman.

7
JoywalkingOP•

That's really good advice -- using this as a learning experience for whenever. I am hoping that repeated exposure will show me to be the boring, normal, friendly person that I am. :)

2
tmofee•

it's kind of hard. i've had many a similar conversation with the GF. She's married, and the hubby is the typical male "don't express any feelings whatsoever". it's still new and hard to get around, considering my long distance lover's BF is the complete opposite (last time we all were toegether we got happily wasted and chatted about it openly. it helped a lot).

you're doing nothing wrong here, but you might want to tread carefully with these two. there MIGHT be issues there, or you all might be happier if you spend time not as a group. speak to your BF and let him know your concerns.

3
JoywalkingOP•

Yeah, thanks. I don't think there are plans for the three of us to hang out, but this was more letting her get to know me enough so that I didn't take on some sort of mythic "successful older woman/predatory cougar" aura that is so not the case.

We're feeling it out. This was just a first tentative toe in the water. Like all my dating/sexual exploration, just taking it step by step.

3
cypherpunks•

I agree with your reading of the situation, both before and during dinner.

You can talk to him for some back-story, but if you feel up to dealing with her some more, talking to her directly might be useful; perhaps she can be more genuine if she's not playing to an audience.

There are two versions of this:

  • Talk about what happened. More direct and honest, might cause more protestations of innocence.
  • Find a pretext. Like coordinating birthday presents or something. This can still be useful at conveying "we don't have to compete" but such indirect approaches can be misinterpreted.
3
mixiemixie•

Yikes. It sounds like everyone was on edge and nervous.

However... I know when I'm nervous I talk a lot especially if someone I didn't know was in my house actively trying to be unintimidating.

Maybe she was just a nervous talker. Have you talked to your guy about how you felt?

3
JoywalkingOP•

I'm giving it a day or so, let everyone unruffle their feathers and have something more than just a knee-jerk reaction. I know I've gotten over some of my "well, THAT wasn't comfortable" in the last 36 hours, so I'm giving everyone a little time to get to a more lasting reaction.

Life is weird, y'know? :) Gotta roll with the weird, sometimes.

2
mixiemixie•

I think its been enough time... 36 hours is plenty for most people. I'd shoot him a text or give him a call soon before they both come to their own conclusions about how you behaved too.

1
JoywalkingOP•

I've sent him a note asking for a check in, and gotten back a "all is essentially well, but she's struggling with bigger issues" response. He's set up our next date night, so that's not been brought to a close.

I do think they're going through some pretty common polywobbles -- he's having more success in the scene than she is, she's got an insecure employment situation, and all of it is conspiring to not help her self-esteem. So I'm just in the right place at an awkward time.

3
constant_craving•

But I also don't want to put myself in a lot of situations where I don't feel welcome -- where I am to be audience rather than a guest.

Then, from your description, you need to date a different person.

2
JoywalkingOP•

Well, most of the time, I won't be hanging around them both. This was unusual, in "their" space. They have a long history of being fine with mutual non-monogamy -- but I'm somehow tweaking some feelings that seem to surprise them both. I don't quite understand it, so I'm not explaining it well.

1
[deleted]•

IME, when the primary isn't comfortable being around the secondary (and so forth) it tends to lead t problems down the road. Be careful.

3
JoywalkingOP•

I am hoping it's newness nerves, but I'm aware of the same issues. Thanks.

2
[deleted]•

Good luck!

1
cyanocobalamin•

They're officially non-monogamous rather than poly, but apparently there's something about he and I that's a bit more than their traditional non-monogamy and making her a little insecure.

Does that mean that they are free to have sex with other people, but not get emotionally involved?

Is the wife currently seeing someone else as well?

1
JoywalkingOP•

They do FWB and playmates, but shy away from emotional attachment beyond that. She has some of those friends, but maybe not as many, as I understand it.

1
cyanocobalamin•

That explains it. She sees you as getting emotionally closer than the other women he has had on the side. That is a threat to her and her territory.

1