Terrible GM here, would you mind helping me out?
So I'm not a very good DM. So there's that. I'm DMing cause we got sick of another players game and wanted something else, so I offered to have a go and well... It's not going as well as I'd imagined...
I have the players in a war scenario. A war between Elves and Dwarves and I'm not sure where to go. Here are the players: A Diplomatic Religious Pacifist, A Pirate that's always drunk, a thief, two Magi, and Ranger/Scout (I'm not really sure of his intentions) and a Dwarven Drunkard Fighter. It's a roleplay heavy campaign and I reward for good roleplaying, but with war setting I'm not sure where to go with them and all that. If I could get some advice from some of my piers, I'd surely appreciate it! Also, this is in 3.5 homebrew campaign.
Posted May 19, 2013, 3:06 AM UTC · edited
My biggest advice for DMs is to run the world and let the players act in that world.
Don't aticipate or force the players.
I have found by running the world when players do something unexpected then I can react naturally and in a relaxed way.
With your campaign I would ask myself - why are the elves and dwarves at war? Is there a large vein the dwarves have dug into that is below and elven forest?
I would find it funny if the dwarves were using an magic device that exploded setting the forest ablaze. A complete accident but when the elves retaliated the dwarves felt that they hit too hard after what could only be called an 'accident'.
How would the dwarven forman / lord react? And the lord of the elves what would his motivations be?
How does this war effect the neighbouring human town - that enjoys the riches of the dwarves but feels loyal to the elves becuasee of the Battle of the Fallen Star - some 2 generations ago - where the elves helped defend the town from the maurading orcs?
Do the orcs to the north want in on some action since the dwarves and the elves are focused on each other?
By knowing the world you can then roleplay as needed. You can create adventures around the town where they start with the war being the background.
The Dwarven mining thing is a pretty nifty idea...
Just to reinforce: listen to all of nbktdis' advice. If you have a world, you'll have no worries as to what should happen next regardless of what your players do.
Don't forget alliances and reasons for that. If its role play heavy you need lots of reason and backstory.
Do the Gnomes join the dwarves because they are friends or does this sunder their friendship.
Are Dwarven Druids fighting alongside the elves?
Who teams up with the usual enemy races or Goblin, Orc, and Drow.
Are the humans Switzerland? Maybe try to sway them from being neutral...