r/DnD•
chewyice

Terrible GM here, would you mind helping me out?

So I'm not a very good DM. So there's that. I'm DMing cause we got sick of another players game and wanted something else, so I offered to have a go and well... It's not going as well as I'd imagined...

I have the players in a war scenario. A war between Elves and Dwarves and I'm not sure where to go. Here are the players: A Diplomatic Religious Pacifist, A Pirate that's always drunk, a thief, two Magi, and Ranger/Scout (I'm not really sure of his intentions) and a Dwarven Drunkard Fighter. It's a roleplay heavy campaign and I reward for good roleplaying, but with war setting I'm not sure where to go with them and all that. If I could get some advice from some of my piers, I'd surely appreciate it! Also, this is in 3.5 homebrew campaign.

Posted May 19, 2013, 3:06 AM UTC · edited

1319
nbktdisDM•

My biggest advice for DMs is to run the world and let the players act in that world.

Don't aticipate or force the players.

I have found by running the world when players do something unexpected then I can react naturally and in a relaxed way.

With your campaign I would ask myself - why are the elves and dwarves at war? Is there a large vein the dwarves have dug into that is below and elven forest?

I would find it funny if the dwarves were using an magic device that exploded setting the forest ablaze. A complete accident but when the elves retaliated the dwarves felt that they hit too hard after what could only be called an 'accident'.

How would the dwarven forman / lord react? And the lord of the elves what would his motivations be?

How does this war effect the neighbouring human town - that enjoys the riches of the dwarves but feels loyal to the elves becuasee of the Battle of the Fallen Star - some 2 generations ago - where the elves helped defend the town from the maurading orcs?

Do the orcs to the north want in on some action since the dwarves and the elves are focused on each other?

By knowing the world you can then roleplay as needed. You can create adventures around the town where they start with the war being the background.

13
chewyiceOPRogue•

The Dwarven mining thing is a pretty nifty idea...

2
zombie_owlbear•

Just to reinforce: listen to all of nbktdis' advice. If you have a world, you'll have no worries as to what should happen next regardless of what your players do.

4
KillsittyCleric•

Don't forget alliances and reasons for that. If its role play heavy you need lots of reason and backstory.

Do the Gnomes join the dwarves because they are friends or does this sunder their friendship.

Are Dwarven Druids fighting alongside the elves?

Who teams up with the usual enemy races or Goblin, Orc, and Drow.

Are the humans Switzerland? Maybe try to sway them from being neutral...

2
Arwin915•

You seem to have set yourself up to be in a tight spot. I wouldn't of attempted a homebrew campaign until I had a fair bit of experience under my belt. (Not to say I didn't anyways, but still.) My suggestion? Practice improvising. Give the players a bunch of different plot hooks and let them decide where they want it to go. You just have to be ready to roll with what they throw at you while keeping some semblance of a plot. Once you get involved enough with a plot hook or two, you can develop that into something bigger.

2
Imagicka•

Your players are looking for adventure and roleplaying but it doesn't sound like there is any particular goal in mind. Why is that?

Are they just a ragtag crew neutral and unsympathic to both factions of the war? Are all the characters neutral in the war? Do they want to become an active part of it? How involved do you want them to become?

Perhaps the most important factor is the motivations of the characters and their respective players. Knowing about and helping to shape and develop those motivations help to drive the game and keep things interesting and engaging.

In regards to running a campaign within the backdrop of a war is ambishious but it also makes things easier because it is a time of chaos and change. There are lots of stories to be told and lots of adventures to be had. Steal liberally from your favourite war stories in movies and books.

If you have some sort of story or theme in mind in regards to using the war as a literary device. Just remember the chaotic nature of the players influence on their own storylines. Do not become frustrated if your triumphs in the war take a backseat to the players interests.

2
antonspohn•

What started the war? What are the player's goal? What is the BBEG? What is your desired end for the game?

1
chewyiceOPRogue•

This is the stuff I'm trying to flesh out, really... And the player's goals? They don't even know yet.

1
antonspohn•

When you get a few more details down I will be able to help you more.

Until then I will posit more questions to get those brain juices flowing. Ilithidae prefer to have an intellectually stimiulating conversasion with their meal before slurping it down. Makes the lobes tender.

What sort of monsters do you enjoy fighting? Do you want thisto be a standard adventure world or something unique? What items do you enjoy using?

Have you already started the campaign?

0
antonspohn•

One way you could approach the war with is that no one remembers why it was started.

Also a list of player races in addition to their classes would be useful.

1
chewyiceOPRogue•

Oh, right. Well there's the Dwarf (Fighter), two Halflings (Pacifist and Ranger), and 4 Humans (Pirate, 2 Magi, and the thief).

1
chewyiceOPRogue•

The campaign is started and they've gained a couple levels through a few misadventures. They insist on making the pacifist the leader, which I am finding incredibly amusing, but also very difficult to play off of since all his actions don't involve fighting and would rather talk it out... Anyway, the adventure can be very unique, but that's all based on where they go with the stuff I put in front of them. Items have all been pretty random, and I've been trying to give them magic items, but the Vow of Poverty pacifist sells everything and donates all his portion to the poor through the church he set up under his god. I think I've given them too much money honestly...

1
antonspohn•

Wait, is the pacifist a monk?

Who's side are the PCs on currently?

1
Self-CookingBaconRogue•

It sounds to me like the players want to be able to settle the conflict in large part non-violently, or at least without endangering themselves. You might want to have a higher-up in the chain of command notice them. This way, they can rise up to a more notable position, and therefore potentially earn the ear of the ruler, which would allow them to use their diplomatic ability more. It doesn't eliminate the possibility of fights since they would still be a part of the army, and if they're traveling with the soldiers they command, I doubt it will feel too static.

Depending on what the players are buying, it may not be too much. If they're spending it on trinkets and novelties, then it probably won't help them unless they find an NPC who happens to be fascinated by them. If they are trying to find the most powerful items and buy them, then it could be a problem potentially.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Conbz•

I've recently started DMing my friends in our first ever game and obviously they're exploring the boundaries of what they're allowed to do, so I've pretty much given them free reign within reason (our Lawful Good druid decided to beat on a woman for no reason so I put a stop to it, it's important to let them do what the want but not to ruin the narrative of their own character, don't let them do that)

Mostly, I decide on a quest I'd like the PCs to do and then facilitate that into what they're already doing, for example, our ridiculously buff Half-elf decided he'd wrestle a dwarf in a contest of strength and from that I put the dwarves into the quest-line and they were the link. It's shockingly easy to lead people if you don't let on that they're being lead.

  • You could have them meet a band of dwarves fighting something fairly standard (Orc, Goblins, Ogres, Etc) and if they decide to help the dwarves ask them to join them for their fighting skills and whatnot, from there they end up talking to increasingly higher army ranks until you can lead them into whatever fights they want.

  • Remember - PCs like shiny things. The promise of a funky sword or a magical ring will often be enough for PCs to brave any number of things, use loot well and you'll have the perfect carrot to lead the PC donkeys

1
[deleted]•

I have found, that planning too far ahead can be a bad thing. I usually try to plan out just one session or half a session in advance. Big, over-arching story lines tend to not work well because they pigeon-hole players into your story's triggers. That doesn't mean that you can't have a campaign-setting, it just means that a setting is only a setting and not a must participate sort of event.

Sometimes the only preparation I have is a couple story hooks and an idea in my head about where those lead and what sort of consequences seeing those hooks through will lead to. When I say 'hooks' I mean something that continues some sort of narrative; for example: a noble offers a rewards for something; an NPC goes missing; someone loses something important; orcs are seen close to the city; pretty much anything that could potentially lead to players doing stuff.

Keeping it simple is probably best for new DMs. You don't need to have a christopher nolan type of plot and story progression to have fun playing DND. It really is more about the choices players make than the story line anyways. Work your way through some clique stories to get some experience. Nothing is wrong with using cliques, I have used them before and they work great.

1
Self-CookingBaconRogue•

You might want to flesh out a map. Figure out what cities are like. Where are the centers of trade and fortresses? What are the primary building materials there? What are the general attitudes of civilians towards foreigners or races uncommon to the cities?

What methods of warfare are being used? It's not likely just "charge the enemy". Poisons are likely being used, assassins might come for generals or the rulers themselves, there are ambushes. In the case of ambushes, elves are probably more in touch with hiding behind trees whereas dwarves might prefer to roll boulders at passing enemy troops. What about naval battles, or do dwarves hate or fear the sea or get seasick too easily? Naval battles could provide some diversity in scenery and fighting style, otherwise the elves could invade the dwarves' unprotected shores. And what about using trained animals in combat? Has either side tried throwing diseased bodies at the other? To be honest, this part may be unlikely due to the Cure Disease spell, but if prisoners fell ill, the clerics might let the prisoner die and then use the illness to rob the enemy clerics of a few of their spells.

It's likely they'll be traveling with at least a portion of the army at least for a while to come. Perhaps if they move up in rank or go on a mission as a special force (perhaps spying or scouting) they happen across the home of a hermit who once saved the life of one of the rulers, but vanished before the ruler could reward him/her. This might give players a source of information as well as a fun NPC.

1