Just goes to show, with sci-fi sometimes you just have to give it some time.
I watched the first episode of this show and thought, Okay... this sucks. They took DS9, B5 and Firefly, mixed it all together and hoped something good would come of it.
But I gave it a chance hoping something good would come of it...
I'm up to episode 5 (or 6 depending on how you look at it) and I'm really starting to love it. The character development is really good and I want to see these characters go somewhere.
My concern is that it has, so far, been very episodic... granted it's only 5 episodes in and perhaps I'm jumping the gun, but the average Star Trek series would be cancelled by now and then limp along trying to write new episodes while always having the "okay we're done" last episode in mind. If it weren't for the game tie in for this show... who knows.
I'd like to see the long arc start developing in this show sooner than later. These characters need to be going somewhere not just dealing with the next problem to come along and be done with it by the end of every episode.
This can't just be Sheriff Hard-Ass in Space Town and expect to be great.
Please don't let this show stagnate to death.
Posted May 20, 2013, 4:31 AM UTC · edited
You might be jumping the gun. They've already signed on for season 2 and I believe the first season's already set in stone. Sure there's "daily dilemmas" that seem to be resolved within one episode's length but there have been reoccurring themes/stories (like Irisa's "psychic powers" or whatever, or Irisa/Nolan's background) that carry from one episode to another.
I want to say that a majority of the first season is going to be setting up these huge arcs that you speak of. The players are being set in place (E-Rep's involvement and interest in the city. What's under Defiance? The Maglev - and whether or not once it's completed will that open more connection to the the Bay Area), and shtako's going to hit the fan soon.
As most episodic (good) shows, the long arc will probably be pursued nearing the final episode and will probably end with a cliffhanger. I think it's too early to make that kind of observation.
It may have had a slow start but with the news of a second season and the recent crossover material for the game, I'm excited to see where Syfy/Trion will take us!
Not to mention the end of the pilot w/ the old mayor seemingly involved in some kind of "greater good" plot against Defiance.
I hope you're correct. This is one of those shows that seems like it has a lot of potential that would be really sad to see it not live up to.
I'd say, if nothing else, at least hold out for episodes 8 and 9. Trion promises a huge-ass crossover between game and show for those two episodes, and that, I think, will be the real litmus test for the cross-media aspect.
True that. Random thought here but I've seen other posts inquiring the skimpy cast list for the video game's voice actors... Maybe they're keeping this under wraps to avoid potential spoilers with voice actors that look just like their in-game characters they portray (thus, revealing that they'd be perfect candidates).
Back to the topic at hand, there's 12 episodes slated for Season 1 so having some big crossover before the third act or so would make sense. Stoked!
I was OP on one of those skimpy cast list posts. Also, I added one of the names on there, Kyle Herbert, after someone on my post linked to his website that laid out what work he did for the game.
Thanks for adding the info! Hopefully we uncover more without spoiling ourselves (too much).
In the game, there was a contest where the winner gets some sort of a part in the show. While cool, hopefully that's not the "huge-ass crossover" event, 'cause it's nice but not mind blowing.
It should also be mentioned that Nolan and Irisa are new to Defiance just like we are, it would be kinda ridiculous to throw them into some epic story arc 1 or 2 episodes in.
What was the Maglev? I have not played the game if that matters.
I'm only about 850 EGO and at Top-Notch Toolworks story hub in the game, but I don't think it's mentioned in the game yet. From what I've gathered from the show, it's a rail system that will give them access westward, at least as far as Oklahoma City (mentioned in this week's episode). This could potentially be a way to physically describe a means of transpo across the Badlands (through an expansion/DLC?). Mayor Rosewater has been pushing for funding for this project since the first episode. Not sure if it's really spoiler material but better safe than sorry.