California is eyeing France's high speed train for a planned link between San Franciso and San Diego
news.yahoo.com/s/afp/20070403/ts_alt_afp/fran...Posted Apr 3, 2007, 11:14 PM UTC
Posted Apr 3, 2007, 11:14 PM UTC
If only Mike Dukakis (spelling) beat Bush the First, we'd all be riding trains. He was a train freak. I've sat in the same subway car that he was using going to work as the Gov of a decent sized state. Imagine ANYONE in the Bush family EVER taking a train other than as a PR stunt.
Meh. California has been "looking into" high speed rail between the Bay Area and the Los Angeles area for decades.
It all boils down to cost. It'll cost BILLIONS of dollars to build it. Hell, we can't even get BART extended a couple miles from Fremont into San Jose.
As much as we claim to love public transportation around here, nobody wants to pay a dime for it unless they plan to use it personally.
The environmentalists would have a high speed rail project wrapped up in courts for decades anyway. They delayed BART to SFO by several years back when that was in the planning stages.
[deleted]
[removed]
[removed]
[deleted]
I hope the freedom train can be realized in the USA
Make Vegas the hub, and I think they'd be on to something.
No matter how many times it is shown to be a bad idea, some people still clamor for it. There already is a rail line that runs along the west coast. It's called the Coast Starlight and it's terrible. It's slower than taking a bus while being more expensive than flying despite the fact that the government is subsidizing part of every ticket: http://www.thelibertypapers.org/2007/03/19/amtrak-slower-than-a-bus-more-expensive-than-flying/
A high speed rail line still wouldn't be as fast as flying (especially if it makes several stops, which it will) and will still cost more (if the current low-tech line is expensive, think how much more a new high-tech line would be).
[deleted]
Besides subsidizing roads and highways, the government also heavily subsidizes fuel. I don't know about jet fuel, but the true price of gasoline has been calculated to be between $5.60 and $15.14 per gallon when all factors are considered.
Save an Iraqi, take the electric train?
why do you think it's so popular in Europe and Japan?
I agree with your comment, but do want to point out that a large majority of train trips in Europe and Japan are basically short trips which I think adds considerably to its popularity, whereas SF->SD is a rather long trip (longer than London->Edinburgh for example).
[deleted]
Comparing Europe and Japan to the U.S. is like comparing apples to oranges. The population density in Japan is so much higher than in the U.S. and there is so much less flat land. And I hardly think rail is "popular" there. When there really isn't a viable alternative to rail then everybody is going to take the rail whether they like it or not.
The only way rail can be faster than flying is if there only a few stops between the start and destination which is rare. Having fewer stops makes a train useful to fewer people, but having more stops makes it slow. The only solution is to have lots and lots of trains, which would require lots and lots of redundant rail lines which is expensive. I don't expect rail to be exempt from subsidies, I'm just pointing out that despite the subsidies it's still far more expensive than the alternatives. Upgrading to an ultra sophisticated rail system isn't going to make it less expensive. So the end result is that you have a system that is just as or more expensive than flying and yet is almost always a lot slower. Sounds like a great idea.
[deleted]
Well it's about time!
what happens to a train traveling that fast when an earthquake happens? just curious.
with or without passengers?
(satisfying yerr morbid sense o'curiosity, eh?)
You can off-course put half the defence budget into infrastructure improvements. Who needs all those destruction machines anyway. Defend the homeland, but stop destroying other countries and bring your troops home. Spend the money on healthcare and high-speed trains instead. You will feel better about yourself.
...hey also high speed (upload) internet!