Would it be stupid to gift them a story?

So I have tickets to meet them at the PHX CreepCast show. I would love to give them a gift but honestly I’m not an artist or can really think of much. Would it be stupid to gift them a short horror story written by myself? I don’t want them to read it on an episode or anything, just figured it would be a fun idea to gift them a short horror story. Writing is my forte and listening to the podcast inspired me to pick writing back up and work on my writing skills, especially expanding more on ideas for monsters and antagonists in my stories and more unique themes for a story. I guess I just wanted insight if this would be a stupid idea for a gift to give them at the meet and greet.