r/DnD•
Rushnik72

Player was checked out of my campaign since session 1 then played in it for over a year

DMing

I have been running a homebrew campaign for around a year, then had to take a year long hiatus for unrelated personal reasons. When I asked if my players wanted to play again, everyone agreed except one player who said they would not be returning. They gave me their reasons but the part that makes me feel the worst is the fact that they were checked out of my campaign from session 1, gave me very little feedback to improve the experience for them, but then proceeded to play for an entire year.

One of the main reasons they left was a rule dispute that happened in session 1, which was completely my fault. What happened was the player had cast a spell, but had flavored it as them throwing essentially a magical molotov cocktail at an enemy. I like to describe what is happening during the combat to the players, so when the spell missed, I said something around the lines of, "the bottled slipped early from your fingers, and you throw a fly ball at the enemy". I let the enemy take a reaction and attempt to catch it, which they did. On the enemy's turn, they threw the molotov back, rolling low on their attack, and I gave my player the opportunity to catch it, which they also did. When it was my player's turn again, they threw the molotov and it hits this time. In all this wasted around 1 round of combat for him and the enemy.

Normally if I mess something up, my players let me know and I redact what happened, especially if it relates to a class ability or spell they are using. In this instance, instead of correcting me that the molotov should not be catchable (as it was functionally a spell), they sat in silence and let it happen.

The second reason they left was also my fault and could have been completely avoided if I was a better dm. To keep things short, there were a lot of failed skill checks from the party, the enemy passed nearly all of their skill checks, and I did not give enough warning / double checking opportunities to my players for their current situation. The results of this was the party was framed by the enemy for stealing something very important from a city and being arrested. I also made a huge mistake in making the guards that arrested them basically bad cops who just wanted someone arrested and didn't care who, so there was not much room for them to negotiate or plead their case. This all resulted in 2 sessions feeling rail loaded, after which when they escaped all of the decision making was back to them.

For the second example I have been trying to make sure I never make a mistake like that again and work with my players to make sure they aren't being forced in any one direction.

But for the first example, should I narrate less what is happening during a fight and just state the attack hits or misses? I like being descriptive to help get everyone more invested in what is happening in the game / story, but was this crossing a line describing how a characters attack missed? I know some dms have "critical failures", where players will stab themselves or their swords will break on natural 1s, but should this instance be in the same category?

Lastly, has anyone experienced something similar with a player keeping quiet for a long time, only to let you know they do not enjoy the campaign?

Sorry for all the questions, this situation has left me doubting my abilities as a dm.

Posted Sep 6, 2024, 7:39 PM UTC

111

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 11 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.