[deleted]•

[removed]

32
thevalarauk•

Perhaps they could have shot Chewie, but maybe the orders didn't make that clear.

Typical racist remark from squigs. His history of prejudice against Wookies is well documented. Of course he would assume that the pilot had to be a human. We're lucky Lord Vader wasn't so backwards thinking!

Don't think he's a racist? Just look at this:

Chewbacca is a Wookiee from the planet Kashyyyk. But Chewbacca lives on the planet Endor. Now think about it; that does not make sense! Why would a Wookiee, an eight-foot tall Wookiee, want to live on Endor, with a bunch of two-foot tall Ewoks?

I rest my case.

36
kermityfrog•

What makes you think that Chewie lives on Endor? He never visited Endor before the 2nd Death Star blew up, or he would never have fallen for the old "meat hanging on a stick" trick - when everyone was caught in an Ewok net.

8
Shaper_pmp•

It's a South Park reference.

Plus, I believe I remember hearing something from a friend about Chewbacca staying on Endor after the events in Return of the Jedi, but that's either non-canon "expanded universe" stuff or just me misremembering.

2
willia4•

I'd always thought that the Star Wars expanded universe was considered canonical (until Lucas pulls another movie from some dark abyss anyways). Has that changed or was I just badly misinformed?

2
utbandit•

This is the funniest thing I have read on reddit in a Looooong time.

Bravo!

21
dasil003•

The last one is the best. "Why is there a chasm in my throne room? What purpose does it serve?"

18
EggCoroner•

Where did the garbage monster come from?

7
kermityfrog•
14
[deleted]•

You know, I always wondered what the purpose of that monster was. How did he get there? How long has he been there? Wouldn't he die the first time they compacted the trash?

And while we're on the topis... why even bother to compact the trash anyway? Why not just blast it into space or into some star, or even dump it on some planet. It's not like the empire really cared about the environment or anything. They blew up entire planets!

19
kermityfrog•

The dianoga is a garbage parasite, not sure how it got there, but probably from water that was sucked up from a planetary body of water. No details of the life cycle of a dianoga, so perhaps they start off spore sized, to get through filters.

The compacter was half filled with water. There are probably underwater channels that the monster could escape from, but people wouldn't unless they could hold their breath a long time.

The trash is compacted because trash is stored until the space station or star destroyer moves. When a large spaceship is stationary, any trash ejected would float in the near vicinity of the spaceship and probably be attracted to it gravitationally. That's why the star destroyer ejected trash prior to going into hyperspace, instead of constantly.

The death star is a mobile space station, but only moves occasionally. It's much more massive, so trash would stick to it more easily. Trash is compacted so that it would take up less room on the station until it could be safely ejected prior to going into hyperspace.

It all makes a lot more sense that one would think!

24
[deleted]•

Only because there's an army of a hundred million dweebs bending over backwards to explain every mistake George Lucas made when he copied Dune.

22
stutheidiot•

On the Implausibility of the Death Star's Trash Compactor

... If the Empire insists on ejecting trash into space, why do they bother compacting it? Space is infinite, is it not? In such an environment, it hardly matters what size the trash is. ...

18
WildYams•

Here's the problem with the Death Star ejecting trash into space: the Death Star was so large as to be mistaken for a small moon, and at that size (versus how relatively small Star Destroyers were), it's quite likely that any garbage that is dumped into space by the Death Star would simply cling to the Death Star's gravity field and crash against the Death Star's hull. While loose garbage might not pose any threat to breaching the hull, certainly all that garbage would begin to pile up.

11
breakneckridge•

True, but the Death Star is the size of a moon, right? It could make a lot of sense to squish the garbage before it has to go on a long trek to the surface where it can be ejected. Otherwise you'd have to have GIANT garbage chutes radiating throughout the entire death star.

4
EternalNY1•

What if he was living in the last batch of trash they threw in there? If that was the case, he wouldn't have been compacted yet and would die along with the rest of them.

12
[deleted]•

Well I never thought of that. Now I feel bad for the little guy.

18
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
shimei•

Maybe the output of the compactor is sent to some Imperial recycling center.

6
[deleted]•

Could be. It doesn't make sense in terms of saving space, but it would be nice to recapture the energy used to process the raw materials.

3
ASmileInHisShoes•

Wouldn't he die the first time they compacted the trash?

Perhaps you'll recall that it released its prey and disappeared -- mysteriously, it seemed at first -- just as the compaction cycle began.

Yes, I know I'm a huge nerd, thank you.

why even bother to compact the trash anyway?

Right there with you on that one.

5
pascha•

Its mother and father.

4†
brainburger•

No. It isn't.

23
[deleted]•

You're response does not effect me in any way.

9
philh•

When two garbage monsters love each other very much...

19
fnord123•
3
exobyte•

There are two possibilities: it was either a plot device to add a little action, or it has some BS explanation that proves nerds are too obsessed with Star Wars.

3†
clinintern•

Are there any of these e-mails from Lord Helmet to the worst engineer in Space Balls?

4
willia4•

He's not really a bad engineer; he's just your basic Asshole.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
hudson701•

You spelt 'apperatis' wrong - should be apparatus.

-4
EventHorizon•

meh. Would have been funnier if it was done as a pr database.

-18
[deleted]•

[removed]

-31
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0