Thoughts on ETFs vs Mutual Funds
Hi Everyone,
It's my first time posting here but I'll try to make this as straightforward as I can:
I'm a recent grad and landed a good job making just over $70k/yr. I've worked for almost exactly 1 year now. I've managed to save: ~$10k in my 401k, ~$10k in checking/savings ~$10k in my brokerage account. I have terrible spending habits however, and in an effort to curb my spending and learn a little bit about the market I've opened said brokerage account. I've been lucky and made a little money this year playing a few stocks and recently moved another $6500 into the account [Now slightly over $10k].
But now I'm starting to worry that the market can't maintain its momentum much longer. Stock prices of companies I'm interested in are at ~5 year highs and it's making me think now isn't the time to jump in.
I've now shifted my focus to ETFs. I'm looking at: FEMS, VOO, XAR, SPLV, VONV.
I like the idea of owning ETFs better than stock since they allow me to diversify my investments despite my lack of buying power. The idea of generating and reinvesting dividends is nice too. But again, every ETF that I'm interested in is priced at an all-time high.
Now I'm looking at mutual funds, VEIPX, and other Vanguard MFs to be exact. Staking my claim would mean making a $3000 minimum investment, and a $10 dollar transaction fee. If I go with the mutual fund route I'd imagine I would like to throw in some extra money every (or every other) month, these fees would add up quickly. I've run into multiple sources that rant and rave about this "excellent" mutual fund and why mutual funds are generally conservative positions.
I have about $10k in my brokerage account right now, I'd like to keep $2500 for trading(/gambling) and invest the remaining $7500 in the mutual fund, EFT(s), or a combination of both.
Could you guys/gals explain why one route would be better or worse than the other? Am I fundamentally misunderstanding anything? Is now even the right time to consider moving money out of the bank?
I'd appreciate any insight, and look forward to your opinions, sources, and educational materials.
Thank you kindly!
Posted Jun 3, 2013, 4:55 AM UTC
If the mutual funds track some index, then you will have the same gross returns as an ETF. If the mutual funds are managed by someone, then you'll most likely get screwed either in returns or in fees or in both.
If the returns are going to be the same, then you just need to check the fees that you have to pay for each one, and how easy it is not only to invest but also to divest your position. I would say ETFs are the way to go 90% of the time.
And as for the market being in all time highs, be aware that no one really knows how high it will go and that timing the market is not something that you should try to do unless you know what you are doing. Look into dollar cost averaging, I think it is a good method for times like these.
Also, if you have terrible spending habits, just track all your expenses in a spreadsheet. It is not that difficult to get into the habit of asking for all the receipts and then entering them when you get home (you'll most likely do around 5 purchases a day on average). Just seeing the expenses one by one creates a very strong feedback loop to make you think on each expense beforehand.
You shouldn't do it to begin with. Timing the market is not a viable investment strategy.
Well, I didn't want to ruffle the feathers of the technical analysis crowd, so I gave them the benefit of the doubt there.