ELI5 Enchanting Weapons/Armor

So creating wondrous items is fairly easily explained but improving existing magic weapons and armor confuse me. What feats/caster level/ etc is required for example to make a +1 long sword to a +2? Does caster level go up the more enchantments on an item? Say I have a +1 flaming scimitar do I need a higher caster level to make that +2 than the previously mentioned long sword?

Posted Jun 5, 2013, 2:41 AM UTC

38
KazajiDM/Tower shield surfer•

Feats? Craft Magic Arms and Armour.

Caster level? 5th

So you take your bitchin' longsword. You wanna make it +1? Sit down for 2 days (2k is the price for +1, and it's 1 day per 1k), spend 1000g (half of cost), and it's +1!

You wanna add Flaming to it? That's +1 weapon + Flaming (+1) = +2. +2 is 8k. You already have it at +1 (2k), so 8k - 2k = 6k. So you sit down for 6 days (1 day per 1k), pay 3k (half of 6k), and it's a beautiful +1 Flaming Longsword.

Nothing scales, no other requirement are needed, other than having the actual gold cost ready. The DC to make it is pretty much irrelevant, since you can just take 10 on the craft and even with a low spellcraft, you'll still make it.

3
PriestmanXLawful Slutty•

Nothing scales, no other requirement are needed, other than having the actual gold cost ready

Some DMs might require you to be in a town by an anvil, or have the actual materials for it, so you cant just enchant a weapon off in the wilderness. But that's DM discretion :)

2
KazajiDM/Tower shield surfer•

Some DMs might require you to be in a town by an anvil, or have the actual materials for it, so you cant just enchant a weapon off in the wilderness.

Keep in mind that, while logical, it's not actually a requirement. You just need to be somewhere where you have a quiet work environment. Also, there's an option specifically for crafting out in the wilderness (at 1/4th speed, though).

Then again, it's a fairly safe assumption to say: if you're crafting for 4+ days straight, you're going to be in a town. :P

2
PriestmanXLawful Slutty•

Oh yeah for sure, I had a DM though that was less practical about such things. Even the few towns we had been to in 3 months of training were just not developed enough to have a blacksmith :/ because that makes sense...

2
Eunoshin•

Wait, I thought 1 day per 1k was in terms of the cost to the crafter - i.e. an upgrade is 2,000, to craft it yourself is 1,000, so it only takes 1 day to create it.

Edit: Also, isn't there something specific about (At least for flat enhancement bonuses), you must have a caster level of 3x the enhancement bonus? Or is that only for Wondrous items?

1
darthmarth28Veteran Gamer•

Semi-Correct and Correct.

The DC to craft an item is a Spellcraft or Craft: relevant check with a DC of 5+the CL of the item in question.

By adding +5 to the DC of the item, you can craft it at double rate, effectively changing the craft time to 1 day per 1000gp you actually spend as opposed to 1 day per 1000gp of the market price. For another +5, you can also bypass any other single requirement of the item you are crafting, so a Wizard can scribe Cleric scrolls, and a Ranger can craft wondrous items for the party.

1
darthmarth28Veteran Gamer•

The Caster Level is another requirement worth noting, here. The CL requirement of any magic weapon or armor item is 3*[Enhancement Modifier] - so in order to take your +4 Longsword to a +5, you need to be character level 15. Note that this refers to the actual Enhancement... not the effective enhancement for purposes of determining price. Each miscellaneous enchantment (Flaming, Keen, etc.) has its own CL restriction. So, a Level 12 Wizard can make a +4 Keen Flaming Burst Abberation Bane Mighty Cleaving Longsword, but he can't make a +5 Longsword.

Note, though, that Caster Level is technically one of the item crafting requirements that can be bypassed by adding +5 to the DC 5+CL Spellcraft check required to craft an item... in other words, its almost trivial.

Yes, this does mean that a level 3 wizard with Craft Wondrous Items can, given enough money and time, craft a Robe of the Archmagi. Pathfinder crafting is kind of dumb, especially at higher levels when the time it takes to craft these things is in the range of months rather than days. Incidentally, another trivial +5 to the DC you can take is to halve the crafting time - very handy.

1
tgruszOutsider Native•

To enchant a weapon, you need Craft Magic Arms and Armor.

If a weapon is at least Masterwork quality, or you have Masterwork Transformation cast upon it, you can enchant it.

Enchantments come in three forms: Enhancement, Special Ability, Fixed Cost.

You must have an Enhancement bonus before you can add a Special Ability or Fixed Cost enchantment.

The Spellcraft for making it is 5 + Caster Level, which varies for the Special Ability or Fixed Cost enchantment.

For a Enhancement bonus, the Caster Level is 3 x Enhancement Bonus.

If you don't meet a pre-requisite, unless you can have someone else provide it, such as by casting a cleric spell you don't have, you increase the DC of the check by 5.

Theoretically, that means a +5 (Caster level 15) sword is a DC 25 spell craft for a lower level mage. If you have a good Spellcraft and a flexible GM, that's not impossible much sooner than it should be, but it's going to be a bit broken for the fighter do be doing BAB + 5 + Strength to hit and +5 + Strength to damage even when they are not using Power Attack.

Special materials (e.g. Mithril, Cold Iron, Adamantine) usually add an upfront cost to the item, and as far as I know only Cold Iron or near equivalents add a cost to enchanting the weapon. For the most part, Mithril and Cold Iron are popular but silly - +4000 for Cold Iron when the creatures that are weak against it are semi-rare and could potentially be better fought with a bow and cold iron arrows.

Adamantine is the main thing I like to have weapons made out of except for darkwood for bows and other wooden items.

3