Balance/Suggestions/Rant Whatever Bazaar Guide
So I'm ghudda, I used to do stuff in Path of Exile. Bazaar is great, but sometimes it's just... So here's some disjointed unique suggestions I haven't heard yet.
Fourth wall break balance: My main gripe inherent with autobattlers and some kind of tower defence games is that players do not have control. The computer allows you to win or lose by choosing your opponent. Outside of crits the game is 100% predictable. Your table is known, the opponent's table is known, so the computer kind of in a roundabout way pre-decides if you win or lose. Kind of like balatro, the fun is the mystery of an unclear victory condition from way too much stacked math so you just send your hand and see what happens.
If the computer already knows the outcome beforehand, make it pick an opponent that the player will win/lose against that isn't a wildly unbalanced fight. Simulate a fight against 5 random potential opponents, if the player wins/loses 3 or more of those simulations, showcase the fight that resulted in the closest victory/loss. Good luck on determining what heuristics defines a close game.
Goals: Present complaints are to reduce burst Damage, make early game less gamble, shift late-game builds away from 1-shots, shift mid-game builds away from 1-item solutions. Will these suggestions do that? No.
Early Game: Current starting options are one SILVER item (except dooley who gets a bronze core item) and one GOLD tier skill. One of pyg's options can be a golden tier arm's dealer skill, which early on effectively doubles his life pool. Starting options should be...
-
1 choice from 3 bronze skills then
-
1 choice from 3 bronze items then
-
1 choice from 3 bronze skills then
-
1 choice from 3 bronze items then
-
1 choice from 3 bronze skills.
The skill and item choices can't result in an upgrade. At hour 1, day 1, you have 2 bronze items and 3 bronze skills. You get to start with a bunch of garbage. This splits up the power level away from randomly getting lucky with a perfectly synergized setup on day 1. This also improves dooley's early game with a free item. You might be able to identify a build to work into early on or keep it open ended. Presently, I'm about 90% sure if I will win/lose the day 1 and day 2 player fight based solely on my starting item and skill.
Item Upgrade Scaling: Current scaling on many items is wildly inconsistent with some items having diamond tiers that compared to their bronze variants are meaningless upgrades (like yo-yo which gains gumballs worth of damage) or absolutely insane (like crook +25 to +200 damage to all weapons). I enjoy the insane build defining scaling some items have when reaching diamond tier but I feel like it's too easy/lucky to get a singular scaling item to diamond tier too early and sweeping the game for days.
All item upgrade items like wrench should operate like bootstraps and be limited to upgrading lower tier items or upgrading themselves if there are no applicable targets.
And why not buff Knee Brace by increasing the additional item cooldown when upgraded. Does anyone even know you can use knee brace to make cooldown reductions stronger? Are knee brace cooldown reductions a bug, or is it literally an insect wing?
It's hard to ever consider pivoting your build when you're locked in to your upgraded item because it's simultaneously too easy to upgrade your items if you hang on to them and also too hard to upgrade items essential to getting a different build form working quickly. By limiting diamond tier items to about level 10 you're not locked in at level 5 with a diamond tier item.
Level ups:
Remove +2 xp reward from the level up reward table and the +1 xp item from the loot items. HP scaling at higher levels becomes absurd and forcing any additional xp at any point in the game to gain a few more levels results in insane late game life pools. I'd rather win with a build, not just being 5 levels higher and having two or three times as much life. Alternatively, keep in all the xp stuff and cap life gains from leveling at higher levels.
Current level up options include random item upgrades. Level 5 should be "upgrade any bronze or silver item", level 10/15 should be "upgrade any item". Any random upgrade before level 5 should be limited to upgrading bronze items. Any random upgrade before level 10 should be limited to upgrading bronze/silver items. This locks out free diamond tier items until level 10 unless they get very lucky and spend a lot at a shop or event or something. This prevents the items with insane upgrade scaling from hitting diamond so early on while giving builds an obvious guaranteed power spike at level 10.
Proc Rates: Set a maximum proc rate for any item at 2 per second with a buffer for 2 procs, then item procs stack up and enter a queue ordered by the strength of that specific proc to be used as the buffer is depleted. That sounded confusing, but think of it like this. A crazy build causes Pufferfish to be triggered 10 times a second. The first 2 procs fire instantly, the other 8 procs happen one at a time every .5 seconds. If the pufferfish's poison is buffed mid combat and a new proc happens, the stronger poison procs jump in front of the queue and those stronger procs hit the opponent before the weaker procs that happened earlier in the fight.
No item effect should be triggering any faster than a 1 second cooldown item with haste. Builds shouldn't just focus on recursive proc chains but also on buffing the item that is constantly proccing once they've saturated the proc limit.
Monster Skills: Some monster skills are broken if you happen to completely randomly get them. If you kill the radiant corsair and get fiery rebirth, congrats on your 10 wins this run. It's literally better than doubling your life pool. If you fight the thug and get bonk, congrats, you win as your board now includes a hidden iceberg or atomic clock. You might disagree but I think the tuning of some monster skills are legitimately insane. They should be good sure, but like...
-
Current Fiery Rebirth: When you die, remove poison, remove burn, heal to full, acquire 30 burn (meaningless by the time you can acquire this skill)
-
Suggested Fiery Rebirth: When you die, remove poison, heal to full, then acquire burn equal to 16% of your life. This change gives you an additional ~3 seconds of life to beat your opponent as you burn to death, instead of an entire extra life.
-
Current Bonk: Enemy cooldowns have +1 second. This makes enemy items 100% slower at 1 sec cd, 17% slower at 6 sec cd, to 10% slower at 10 sec cd. For reference, the iceberg is a large item that freezes enemy items for 1 sec when they use them, which in a roundabout way, increases cooldowns by 1 second (haste/slow excluded). Bonk is literally as good as having iceberg on the board, if not better, but it operates completely invisibly.
-
Suggested Bonk: Enemy cooldowns have +5% and +0.3 seconds. This makes enemy items 35% slower at 1 sec cd, 10% slower at 6 sec cd, to 8% slower at 10 sec cd.
Misc whatever:
Introduce items and skills that delay/accelerate the sandstorm or convert it into a poison/firestorm.
Pre-Player battles: Show the board, include a wager screen, bet on who wins. Win no coin if you guess wrong. Win 2 coins if you guess right. Take 1 coin if you don't guess. This helps slow the game down and gets people to think about why they won/lost.
Post-player battles: Include an option in the settings to not skip to the next day immediately. Let me look at the enemy board and figure out what the hell just happened. This isn't an issue with sandstorm stall builds as there's plenty of time to see what happens. It is a problem when you fight a burst build and die 1 to 2 seconds after the first item procs.
Presently when choosing an encounter the background effect around the event reflects how "rare" the event is. Jay Jay and Nufu will always have a bronze effect background art. Instead make the background effect for events and for shops be reflective of the tier of item that the event will give you (should you take an item from it) or the highest tier item that shop sells. Sterling has a silver background effect and sells silver items. Goldie has a gold background effect and sells gold items. Luxe has a diamond background effect and sells diamond items. Freiya has a red background effect and sells enchanted items.
Standardize this. A red tier background effect on a shop is guaranteed to have at least one enchanted item. A red tier event will always give an enchanted item (should you take the item). A gold tier Nufu is guaranteed to have a gold tier skill for sale. I normally wouldn't ever take a random small/medium item over like 2g+1xp, but if I saw the diamond background and I knew I was going to get a random diamond item I might take the gamble, or sell value. Does any of this sound cool or interesting?
-
A diamond tier gumball machine that sells diamond tier gumballs?
-
A gold tier treasure chest that gives a guaranteed gold tier random item?
-
A red tier bazaar-con, meaning one of the small items are enchanted, or take the 12g diamond tier item which is enchanted.
-
A silver tier Curio shop that has some silver tier junk items.
This also informs the player of how late the game is actually going. When you encounter shops late on day 13 and beyond, they're full of gold and diamond items but the shop background is the same bronze effect as if it was the same shop you encountered on day one.
I'll probably think of other stuff but I'm kind of tired of writing at this point.
tl;dr increase item upgrade scaling and make upgrading easier, but make upgrading to higher tiers harder early on. Balance the power you get from upgrading most items. Reduce the power of the single starting item and skill. blah blah blah.
Posted Nov 18, 2024, 6:12 PM UTC