AITAH for giving my fiancée an ultimatum about our future?
My fiancée(30f) and I(33m) have been together for about 7 years, engaged for 1. I left my parents home at 17 because I had no other choice if I wanted to either get a job or go to post secondary school. This has led to me having lived in MANY different locations in my lifetime, and I am grateful for the experiences and the people I have lived with has taught me a lot about life and myself.
My fiancée on the other hand, has never lived with anyone other than her parents. Her siblings, who are older than her (34m and 36m), also have never left, despite both of them having decent well paying careers. They constantly tell me it's just the "Asian culture" to not move out of your parents home until you're married.
I moved out into my own place 4 years ago, telling my partner that I really wanted her to move in with me as at this point we had been together for 2-3 years and I had prior experience living with a partner, so I know that the dynamic completely changes once you actually live together. She would always say she'll think about it but nothing happened. After about a year, my place got flooded by an incompetent upstairs tenant so I was forced to stay at my brother's place until I could find a new place. I guess she saw this as a bullet dodged for her.
A few months later, I decided to rent a basement apartment from HER BROTHER, with very cheap rent. Yes, he owns a home but still lives with their parents. Once again, I stayed there for about a year, telling her constantly how I wanted her to move in with me, but she just wouldn't. Eventually I left because I was tired of feeling like I was taking advantage of her brother, especially given his sister wasn't even living there. Again, I moved back in with my brother, this time vowing that I wouldn't be moving again without her.
It's been about a year since then and we ended up having a massive argument a while ago about how I just don't see a future with us the way things are going. I told her about how angry and resentful I am that twice over 4 years she has left me on the hook waiting for her to get out of there and start living independently of her parents home. She's 30 years old now and I'm 33, I am tired of feeling like I am with someone who is a perpetual teenager. She has a career. She can earn more money than I can with her education, yet I feel like that because she can just stay at home, she has no drive or urgency to pursue more.
She said that it feels like I am giving her a ultimatum, and really, I am. I have told her countless times what I want, and she's always either just ignored me, told me to drop it, or just says she will and doesn't. She won't go get her license to drive, despite my insistence for over 5 years. She won't get a full time job and instead just keeps saying she'll get multiple part time jobs, some of which would be minimum wage and wouldn't even be in her field.
The absolute worst part is that her parents and siblings KEEP TELLING HER that I should just move in with them, to "save money for our future", and they basically keep calling me an idiot for outright declining the offer. I keep getting told "I'm not looking at it from their perspective" while everyone keeps ignoring mine, that I would be extemely unhappy living with them. Of course, she fully agrees with them and is PISSED at me because she's basically being forced to choose between her family or me. Of course, basically every single person I talk to about this who isn't her family says I am right to put my foot down, especially after waiting SO LONG, but yet I can't help feel like I AM the asshole now.
TL;DR: After 7 years, I basically told my fiancée we are moving in together or we are through, despite what her family insists.
Posted Nov 18, 2024, 9:59 PM UTC